Sept 27-28 Premier League discussion

[Runner Ref]

So if you think it might not be a red, is it an error? I think since VAR has been introduced, I can only recalled 2 instances where a red card has been overturned for a yellow card.

Its one of those where I can understand why the ref went for red but if it does not meet the threshold for serious foul play then maybe the VAR should get involved?

I think last season, VAR 100% gets involved. But with the new lighter touch, things need to be 100% obvious for them to get involved. I think there’s enough in this in that red isn’t completely wrong, but neither was yellow.

 

[Paul_10]

I think last season, VAR 100% gets involved. But with the new lighter touch, things need to be 100% obvious for them to get involved. I think there’s enough in this in that red isn’t completely wrong, but neither was yellow.

The general reaction from what I can see is that the red is harsh and for me I don't think it meets the threshold for serious foul play. It just looks reckless to me rather than dangerous/out of control. I'm not surprised the on field call stands but I wonder how much contact Chris Kavanagh thought there was and whether he noticed Fernandes slip which may of affected the way he made the challenge.

 

[David G]

Man United can appeal if they feel it’s wrong. It won’t change the outcome of the game but if they win it would negate any ban.