A&H

Open Age First game of the new year... First ever 3 card trick

Status
Not open for further replies.
CallumRushton13

CallumRushton13

Well-Known Member
Level 6 Referee
Don't you just love some players?? The sort of player who is easily better than anyone else, but can't keep his mouth shut...

Tried the stepped approach with him... Quiet word as I passed. Then obvious work at break in play. Called captain over and have him a public rebuke and final warning... All to no use and on 35 minutes he goes in the book c2... "Sorry ref, I'll stay quiet for the rest of the game"

Tbf to him he did stay quiet for a good 10 minutes!! Last throw in before half time he asks the CAR to go get the ball for him, AR replies with "that's not my job"... Player very aggressively shouts "just get the f****** ball you d***"... Cue second yellow for c1 AA...

Explained to captain why he was off and he is very understanding, happy days.

Two other yellows followed later to seperate player both for reckless play, felt like I was babysitting a bunch of kids with all the whining, not refereeing arguably the best team in the division... Ahh well, roll on next week
 
The Referee Store
Not offensive insulting or abusive imo... More aggressive...

I know what you're thinking thoigh as I was thinking the same myself... Took a post match discussion with a level4 colleague I fully convince myself I was right
 
HertsFinest said:
Sorry? That's nailed on OFFINABUS
Click to expand...

Text book case.

If I was the AR and the ref didnt walk them for that I would be very unhappy.

CallumRushton13 said:
Not offensive insulting or abusive imo... More aggressive...

I know what you're thinking thoigh as I was thinking the same myself... Took a post match discussion with a level4 colleague I fully convince myself I was right
Click to expand...

If you were thinking it, why didn't you do it?

And don't take everything that level 4 and above refs say as gospel.....they have a vested interest in not dealing with S6.......
 
In some areas you greet people as a D*** so it isn't that bad. The fact he's shouted it and already on a yellow a yellow is probably right, the CFA can upgrade it if they wish.
 
Jacko said:
In some areas you greet people as a D*** so it isn't that bad. The fact he's shouted it and already on a yellow a yellow is probably right, the CFA can upgrade it if they wish.
Click to expand...
I have never come across that. People really greet each other with the term d*ck? :) as in "alright d*ck, you down the pub later for a few?"

Come on gents - Callum was the ref on the day, he felt it warranted a (second) caution. We weren't there, he was. You may have done things differently but that does not mean Callum is wrong. In fact, him doing something and not just ignoring it, sounds about right to me.
 
[
CallumRushton13 said:
Not offensive insulting or abusive imo... More aggressive...

I know what you're thinking thoigh as I was thinking the same myself... Took a post match discussion with a level4 colleague I fully convince myself I was right
Click to expand...
If someone calls me that he walks; by extension a player calls an AR that - even a club one - and he takes the same road all day long.
 
SM said:
I have never come across that. People really greet each other with the term d*ck? :) as in "alright d*ck, you down the pub later for a few?"

Come on gents - Callum was the ref on the day, he felt it warranted a (second) caution. We weren't there, he was. You may have done things differently but that does not mean Callum is wrong. In fact, him doing something and not just ignoring it, sounds about right to me.
Click to expand...
Short for Richard. :)

I hear that sort of greeting regularly. Don't understand it but hey-ho.

OT: Regardless of whether it was straight red or second caution you reached the same outcome so not too much to worry about although if he were aggressive when saying it I'd send him off.
 
If you've laid out your rules before on language then you could. I make it clear that I have a very low tolerance for bad language, especially if directed at me. Call me a d*ck then you may meet my yellow and red friends tom and Harry!
 
Jacko said:
How can you say that if you weren't there?

Depending on the volume, manner it was said it could range from nothing, a word, a caution and a red.
Click to expand...

Not relevent as it is quite clearly offensive in the words. If you say it quietly its still offensive!
 
HertsFinest said:
Not relevent as it is quite clearly offensive in the words. If you say it quietly its still offensive!
Click to expand...

I suppose it's down to the opinion of the referee, the context it was said in, the volume, they're factors which I use to decide on what action to take when making a decision on a comment.

If you view it as a red and a different referee views it differently then that's fine. We're never going to be consistent on such things (as a group of referees) as every situation is different the same as every referee.
 
I do not find the word d*** offensive or insulting... A number if other refs I know feel the same. I do find his manner aggressive however. Report will go in today and I will speak to my rdo/coach for their opinion...
 
CallumRushton13 said:
I do not find the word d*** offensive or insulting... A number if other refs I know feel the same. I do find his manner aggressive however. Report will go in today and I will speak to my rdo/coach for their opinion...
Click to expand...

As its a double caution on the wholegame system you don't actually need to write a report.

I would though just to cover yourself.
 
Padfoot said:
Text book case.

If I was the AR and the ref didnt walk them for that I would be very unhappy.



If you were thinking it, why didn't you do it?

And don't take everything that level 4 and above refs say as gospel.....they have a vested interest in not dealing with S6.......
Click to expand...

Didn't do it as I was unsure, both feasible in my eyes and a second yellow was an easier sell...
 
Jacko said:
As its a double caution on the wholegame system you don't actually need to write a report.

I would though just to cover yourself.
Click to expand...
Do you not?? New to me...

Anyway message just sent to coach, who is a well respected level 3 and was given to me through the north west development group so as far as I'm concerned what he says is as close to gospel as I'm going to get...

Would the report (to cover myself) go in through wholegame also?? I may actually ring my cfa chief exec tomorrow to be sure
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top