Runner Ref
RefChat Addict
What did he get correct vs wrong? 
Help keep RefChat running, any donation would be appreciated
Just about everything....What did he get correct vs wrong?
Generous. Can you come observe me please?
Generous. Can you come observe me please?

I’ll take a 77 tomorrow if you’re throwing one out!i believe my marks ranged from 71 to 77 through levels 6, 5 and 4![]()
5 to 4i believe my marks ranged from 71 to 77 through levels 6, 5 and 4![]()
5 to 4
I was 69 (had a mare) through to 76
Averaged 72.6
Back then, scores varied widely from one County to another. There was some daft numbers floating around outside of @Russell Jones Domain
Hopefully, more consistent now
I've averaged 72.65 over 3 seasons as a L4 with one score in particular killing me (71.575, I upset the Observer by telling him he was wrong on a point of fact! Although it subsequently turns out he kills everyone's season)
Yeh, those scores don't exist nowhad one 77 at L4 but unfortunately had a 70 the same season (still incredibly bitter about the observer)
It's happening more and more now, I've heard several referees at L3 return scores of above 74.(although 74.0 is like Pluto, an outlier)
The 5-4 form should be done very similar/the same as step 5/6 and above.I've had one this year where the game went well. Not a whole lot happened but plenty of positives. The observer went standard expected down the middle for the lot. Even boxes where he had written 3 or 4 good things. He mentioned 1 bit of feedback about a possible caution for a challenge but said managing it was fine, still marked it standard expected.
Score came out 70.25. Quite a bit below the needed 71. I now have the same guy observing again.
Just a touch frustrating. As I know on how that specific game went other observers would have given me something to work with.
More chance of a L3 getting a 74 (especially up North) than a L4 for some reason.....It's happening more and more now, I've heard several referees at L3 return scores of above 74.
Generally the games are more challenging and secondly it is not beyond reason that you would expect level 3 referees to be scoring higher than level 4 hence the attainment of a higher level.More chance of a L3 getting a 74 (especially up North) than a L4 for some reason.....
That’s a very decent average in today’s market!5 to 4
I was 69 (had a mare) through to 76
Averaged 72.6
Back then, scores varied widely from one County to another. There was some daft numbers floating around outside of @Russell Jones Domain
Hopefully, more consistent now
I've averaged 72.65 over 3 seasons as a L4 with one score in particular killing me (71.575, I upset the Observer by telling him he was wrong on a point of fact! The debrief went steeply downhill when I realized he hadn't taken my interjection well. Although it subsequently turns out he kills everyone's season. I've seen the scores he's given L3's I've assisted and they've been brutal. He's a name that everyone knows. He and one other in my area are a serious problem. Thankfully, I've not encountered the second murderer)
Which is how it should be. Many years ago when Neale Barry was Head of Referees for the FA, he was exasperated by the average and the high awards of marks and it was his view that the normal game/average should be 70 (not unexpected) and that top end should be 73, with some exceptions above the rule. Slowly but surely and since his departure this has what has now happened. However, the outcome of this is that there are very many Referees squeezed into a certain area, where perhaps only half a mark separates many and therefore those who want to get on are appealing for anything that perhaps could give them a slight edge.Yeh, those scores don't exist now
You'd be very hard pressed to score below 71 (although it does happen. A new L4 I was out with last week got a 69.9 in his first observation which illustrates the point of reaching L4 too quickly) and 73.5 is top end (although 74.0 is like Pluto, an outlier)
Though not always the case James because the expectation expected of a L3 is higher than a L4. So something that may be given as above expected at L4 may only be expected at L3. Having said that a good performance at L3 is stil a good performance, which any Observer needs to be aware of & reflect/reward as best he/she can.Generally the games are more challenging and secondly it is not beyond reason that you would expect level 3 referees to be scoring higher than level 4 hence the attainment of a higher level.
That said as I understand it the marks somewhat tighten up once get to level 2.