If they moan at me I usually try and say something witty to make em laugh. The other week I was doing a youth game and one of the player's shouted "OMG Ref!!! are you having a laugh did you not see that!!" My very vociferous reply to him was "Hashtag, Shut up and get on with it lol" the coaches and the parents on the sideline burst out laughing at this point, the player just shook his head in an embarrassed fashion.
or in a Ladies Match - hopefully!Once, when I refereed a pre season game on march 8th, both teams were particularly moany I said:
"Guys, you are taking this International Womens' day way too seriously. Stop moaning". Got a good laugh. Would never have said it in an official game.
Again.....hopefully said witty remark was made whilst issuing a caution for dissent?
It's all very well belittling players, or children if you consider that perspective, but you don't do yourself, or fellow refs, any favours by not shoving a lemon up there nose.
Maybe if people stopped trying to be clever and simply did the job they were there to do, we would have players less willing to offer their uninformed, misguided and normally loud opinions on every decision?
If you want to be popular and entertain an audience, might I suggest trying stand up comedy instead?
Are you advocating issuing a yellow card for every "moan"
I would respectfully suggest that isn't doing anyone any "favours" either.
There are , effective, alternatives to dealing with mild dissent rather than just banging out a yellow card on every occasion.
Not every moan, but certainly for the 2 clear cut examples of dissent that have been mentioned in this thread.
Out of curiosity, does the LOTG differentiate between 'mild' dissent and 'dissent' or is it really just all dissent?
you dont know the rules ref, quite right player,stunned look, followed by no rules in football 17 lawsNo fella i dont know the rules of football as last time i checked they were laws not rules
or
Really I must be reffing a different game to u player
No it doesn't of course Padfoot.
However "Oh ref" could be classified as dissent, as could "Never in a million years, are you blind?" - I would handle both remarks differently.
Its just not practical to call every disagreement with a decision, "dissent" and therefore a yellow card IMHO.
I come out of the house to get away from people like you!
Step in to my office...just before you dish a card out.....
all I can hear is mumbling....and when they start again....just say can anyone hear that? there it is again
I think you're asking for a comment that will lead to a red card saying any of that. Also risking someone trying to hit you.
I think saying any of that is pretty demeaning, insulting and also makes you come across as a bully.