Fair comments. Yes, I've no doubt there's many Committee Members out there who are less... shall we say 'emotive!' And yes, a civilised discussion could salvage or ensure good marks from them. On the other hand, I've already witnessed 'very awkward' post-match vibes when acting as AR and I had one game this season (R) after which there was no prospect of me getting close to the Committee Room!
My overall feeling however, is that the disconnect between Referees and the wider football-community is a two-way street. The Forum is awash with entirely dismissive attitudes when it comes to footballers, managers and so on. Is it any wonder the divide is so cavernous?
I don't know how the weightings work at higher levels, but there seems a lot of emphasis at 5-to-4 on competencies that are questionable in terms of their importance. I guess it's an apt stage in our development to demonstrate being a 'good allrounder'. Perhaps the weightings are balanced back towards the KMD's the clubs care about at 4-to-3 and above. I don't know (yet)
Yes, you know your clubs and you also know your assistants. I've worked with some assistants that I had to keep a very tight reign on in boardrooms, and depending on what happened in the game I'd say we were going home without any of us going in there as I couldn't take the risk of them saying something that would fan the flames. Appreciate this is South East centric, but you go to clubs like Wingate & Finchley, Oxhey Jets, Haringey Borough and you know that no matter what has happened during the game you will be respected and treat well in the boardroom. Whereas Thurrock had a sign in the officials changing room telling them they were not welcome in the boardroom and would be served sandwiches in their room, on two occasions at Braintree the changing room door opened and sandwiches were pretty much thrown in, and I've been to other clubs where the atmosphere was horrible in the baordroom after.