The Ref Stop

Sheffield Wednesday vs Plymouth

Donate to RefChat

Help keep RefChat running, any donation would be appreciated

The Ref Stop
I made a mistake (not as bad as that) in my 'otherwise very good game' yesterday , yet 'self pity' was not something I felt for myself last night
'On the face of it', that's a dreadful decision

Watching the full highlights on uTube, it doesn't look quite so bad from another angle, but it's still ridiculous to class that as yellow
Whether the player meant it or not, it can't be described as anything other that 'endangering the safety of an opponent', despite the absence of significant injury to The Owl.
What is 'Pro Ref' saying to these Referees?
'Not spoiling the game' is far too much 'of a thing'. Yet the modules I've done over the last few years, suggest my bar for SFP is too high and I should lower my own tolerance. How can I do that when the Pro game is all too often 'lawless' in this respect?
 
Last edited:
I was at this one yesterday and real time, even after one too many sherbets, I thought this was a red card. Having now seen it I am certain. A pity for Anthony Backhouse as he had a very good game aside from this one incident.

I agree with you. However, what I get frustrated with is that Refereeing/officiating is getting worse/or shocking etc. I think what they mean is ‘certain’ decisions, which is fair enough to a degree if this is the case and there is a clear and obvious error rather than a subjective opinion - which in very many cases, it often is. They often don’t even consider all the aspects of a Referees performance eg level fitness/positioning, communication, teamwork etc
 
I agree with you. However, what I get frustrated with is that Refereeing/officiating is getting worse/or shocking etc. I think what they mean is ‘certain’ decisions, which is fair enough to a degree if this is the case and there is a clear and obvious error rather than a subjective opinion - which in very many cases, it often is. They often don’t even consider all the aspects of a Referees performance eg level fitness/positioning, communication, teamwork etc
That the way it goes though. In everyday life, it's typical psychology to massively under-value the good work, if the worst aspect of a job is unacceptable
 
I made a mistake (not as bad as that) in my 'otherwise very good game' yesterday , yet 'self pity' was not something I felt for myself last night
'On the face of it', that's a dreadful decision

Watching the full highlights on uTube, it doesn't look quite so bad from another angle, but it's still ridiculous to class that as yellow
Whether the player meant it or not, it can't be described as anything other that 'endangering the safety of an opponent', despite the absence of significant injury to The Owl.
What is 'Pro Ref' saying to these Referees?
'Not spoiling the game' is far too much 'of a thing'. Yet the modules I've done over the last few years, suggest my bar for SFP is too high and I should lower my own tolerance. How can I do that when the Pro game is all too often 'lawless' in this respect?
I would wager good money that ProRef will include this clip in next Friday's bunch sent to all its officials. And they will simply say it should have been a Red Card. There's definitely an ingrained mindset about 'not spoiling the game' by undue sanctioning of technical offences ... but the clear expectation is that SFP and VC should be properly dealt with.
 
I would wager good money that ProRef will include this clip in next Friday's bunch sent to all its officials. And they will simply say it should have been a Red Card. There's definitely an ingrained mindset about 'not spoiling the game' by undue sanctioning of technical offences ... but the clear expectation is that SFP and VC should be properly dealt with.
It was also quite early in the game which I suspect may well have played a part in the decision making progress.
 
I agree with you. However, what I get frustrated with is that Refereeing/officiating is getting worse/or shocking etc. I think what they mean is ‘certain’ decisions, which is fair enough to a degree if this is the case and there is a clear and obvious error rather than a subjective opinion - which in very many cases, it often is. They often don’t even consider all the aspects of a Referees performance eg level fitness/positioning, communication, teamwork etc
That's the problem though, people with no background in refereeing will just remember the mistakes. As I said, aside from this decision I thought Anthony Backhouse was really good, but most supporters are describing it as one of the worst ever performances because they just remember this incident. That's just human nature unfortunately, luckily it didn't affect the outcome of the match otherwise the protests would be even louder.

Also probably lucky the technical areas are in a weird position at Hillsborough, it meant it was a long way from both of them. Had that happened in front of them I suspect it would have kicked off.
 
My view at the time was it should have been red..seen it back and still think the same, even without my blue and white tints on!
 
I would wager good money that ProRef will include this clip in next Friday's bunch sent to all its officials. And they will simply say it should have been a Red Card. There's definitely an ingrained mindset about 'not spoiling the game' by undue sanctioning of technical offences ... but the clear expectation is that SFP and VC should be properly dealt with.
I think the Elite game has got a serious problem. Let's call it an emerging flaw in the game
The better the standard of football, the more severe the flaw becomes. That is, red cards really do have the strong potential to ruin a game

Take the England game the other night. On this occasion, the red card arguably made for a better game because we made Paella of the Spanish in the first hour and. But normally, the scores are fairly close and a single red card effectively determines the outcome of the game. If it happens early in the game, there's the potential for a 'dead rubber'

So the notion of 'red cards ruining games' is a thing, which makes the stakes very high indeed for the top level referees

FWIW, and this I think is the case on paper, England have (by far) the best National Team in the World. A strong change the World Champions could've been left utterly battered, had Elliott shown some restraint
I still can't see them winning a tournament however. Whilst we shone in the middle of a season the other night, when the players all have their mesocycle fitness peaking, the majority of them are unrecognizable after the rigours of playing the long English season. I know many foreign players are in the same domestic league, but the ratio of exhausted players is disproportionate with respect to the England side
 
I think the Elite game has got a serious problem. Let's call it an emerging flaw in the game
The better the standard of football, the more severe the flaw becomes. That is, red cards really do have the strong potential to ruin a game

Take the England game the other night. On this occasion, the red card arguably made for a better game because we made Paella of the Spanish in the first hour and. But normally, the scores are fairly close and a single red card effectively determines the outcome of the game. If it happens early in the game, there's the potential for a 'dead rubber'

So the notion of 'red cards ruining games' is a thing, which makes the stakes very high indeed for the top level referees

FWIW, and this I think is the case on paper, England have (by far) the best National Team in the World. A strong change the World Champions could've been left utterly battered, had Elliott shown some restraint
I still can't see them winning a tournament however. Whilst we shone in the middle of a season the other night, when the players all have their mesocycle fitness peaking, the majority of them are unrecognizable after the rigours of playing the long English season. I know many foreign players are in the same domestic league, but the ratio of exhausted players is disproportionate with respect to the England side

But it's not the referees fault if it's ruined by a player who has committed a red card offense, the only time it will be if the referee made a mistake given a red and there is either no red card or a VAR has failed to intervene.

As for the England talk then they are doing better against the top ranked nations in recent times, it has been a flaw that their record against the top nations has been underwhelming and unless this team wins a Euros or better still a world cup then maybe you can say we got the best squad in the world. Players are much fitter these days so this talk the players had a tough season domestically does not wash with me. It was not a factor why they retreated against Argentina, that was tactical and the fact Argentina are a better team overall given they are world cup winners unlike England.
 
But it's not the referees fault if it's ruined by a player who has committed a red card offense
Didn't say it was. I said (inferred) it's a flaw in the elite game that red cards effectively decide the game
alk the players had a tough season domestically does not wash with me
So Mo Farah was Olympics ready 12 months a year?
Small margins in elite sport manifest as the difference between winning & losing. The mesocycle is non-existent if constantly on the limit. Athletes crash. Naturally, there's a lot of factors, and of course our tactics against the Argies trumped everything else in that particular game. Nonetheless, The Lions were hardly roaring or purring, throughout the competition
 
Last edited:
I don’t know that I would be deeply disturbed by permitting a sub for a sent off player. (Or permitting a sub after 10 or 15 minutes.)

The no sub is really an artifact of the game. The game had no subs when send offs were created. So of course you had to play short if someone was sent off—same as if someone was injured. When subs first came into the game, it was only one sub, and only for injury. And as we add more fresh legs to the game, the consequences of playing short are also increased. One of the side effects of the no sub is this concept of ruining games with an early red card. So refs are reluctant to send off where it is earned. So despite my regular adherence to tradition, I do wonder if it would be an improvement to make a change on this.
 
Interestingly in the parallel universe of Walking Football, this will be an amendment I will propose for the annual law review next autumn. Obviously walking football is played predominantly by a more senior player so the reduction of numbers in a team due to a sending off can have a massive effect. So I will be recommending that following the issue of a red card that individual is out for the rest of the game (and any local requirements for a multi fixture event) the team play short handed for the period of the single bin that is being used for that particular length of game and at the end of the sin bin a substitute can take the place of the player sent off.
 
Back
Top