The Ref Stop

Rugby Union Red cards

Donate to RefChat

Help keep RefChat running, any donation would be appreciated

DJIC

RefChat Addict
After the Japan 40 second RC yesterday.

Anyone think the 20 minute red card for a technical/accidental RC, would work in football.

Our technical red cards DOGSO, maybe 2nd YC, accidental SFP, if there is such a thing?

Rugby Union: The 20-Minute Red Card (Technical / Accidental)
    • Offenses: Issued for acts of foul play deemed not deliberate or intentional—such as accidental head-on-head contact, mistimed tackles, or high danger plays where a player had a chance to adjust or made an honest miscalculation. Two yellow cards can also result in a 20-minute red card unless the final offense meets a full red card threshold.
    • Player Removal: The offending player is permanently removed from the match and cannot return.
    • Replacement: Exactly 20 minutes after the red card is shown, the punished team can bring on an available substitute to return to a full complement of 15 players on the pitch.
 
The Ref Stop
After the Japan 40 second RC yesterday.

Anyone think the 20 minute red card for a technical/accidental RC, would work in football.

Our technical red cards DOGSO, maybe 2nd YC, accidental SFP, if there is such a thing?

Rugby Union: The 20-Minute Red Card (Technical / Accidental)
    • Offenses: Issued for acts of foul play deemed not deliberate or intentional—such as accidental head-on-head contact, mistimed tackles, or high danger plays where a player had a chance to adjust or made an honest miscalculation. Two yellow cards can also result in a 20-minute red card unless the final offense meets a full red card threshold.
    • Player Removal: The offending player is permanently removed from the match and cannot return.
    • Replacement: Exactly 20 minutes after the red card is shown, the punished team can bring on an available substitute to return to a full complement of 15 players on the pitch.
Not really
We already have the precedent of Sin Bins in football at Step 5 and below
The FA claim dissent has been markedly reduced since their introduction, but that just means grass roots referees are not penalising the same level of dissent properly.
Sin Bins address dissent by raising the stakes for the player, but the idea is negated because it does exactly the same for the Referee. In my opinion, this makes managing 'Sin Bins' the most difficult competency in refereeing, ironically doing so for those referees with the least experience, usually working alone to make matters worse. The nett outcome is dissent has not improved at any level of football
Indeed, if Sin Bins were such a great idea, we'd see the rule employed at every level of the game

We had the idea of a blue card in the Pro game a few years back. The notion got the light of day for no time at all, with the clubs kicking it into touch in the blink of an eye

In essence, the game is set to stay exactly as it is, because there's no real appetite to take any commercial risk with the televised game.
The Pro game is not interested in changing culture, it's all about the dollar. And that will never change, as it never has done for any length of time
 
Back
Top