Red Yellow or No card

[Ciley Myrus]

I can accept no card. And yes the ball is there to be played. But he doesnt win it or play it. This is one of those "50/50s that can go either way" when in reality its not actually a 5050 its more a 5248 so he ends up being late and fouling.

Spot on, only one gets the ball, yellow
Fact remains, black fouls yellow, even if it is by grazing his shoelaces
You need to call a foul here, a nothing foul, for no other reason than if you dont, your setting your stall out saying, go in with feet raised, its ok.

 

[Sheffields Finest]

All this masculinity, a boot could have come off and killed someone... I’m not taking any more chances!

 

[one]

I am somewhat surprised an a little concerned that half those who voted see this as no card. Yes you don't use slow mo for intensity and speed of the tackle but you can use it for point of contact.



Yellow player gets the ball. Black player gets the ankle of the yellow player with the studs. Point of contact facts. That has got to be yellow.

 

[JamesL]

I am somewhat surprised an a little concerned that half those who voted see this as no card. Yes you don't use slow mo for intensity and speed of the tackle but you can use it for point of contact.

View attachment 3115

Yellow player gets the ball. Black player gets the ankle of the yellow player with the studs. Point of contact facts. That has got to be yellow.

Play on, apparently!!!!

 

[Sheffields Finest]

Welcome to common sense @JamesL

 

[Big Cat]

Its not a no contact sport

It is a contact sport, not all contact is a foul
Without seeing the incident in real time, I'd reserve judgement. As usual, I'm leaning towards agreeing with those who are saying 'no card'
If anything, I don't see it as reckless, but a case could be made for PIADM with contact; which I equate to yellow
I don't have a strong feeling either way, especially on account of the debate being held over another slo-motion

 

[Big Cat]

Its not a no contact sport

Sorry, just noticed the double negative

 

[RustyRef]

It isn't about being a contact or no contact sport, one player there has a straight leg and studs showing at waste height. I can buy no red card, I could just about at a push support no caution, but it is at an absolute minimum a foul. As I've said a few times recently, we aren't in the 1980s any more ..!

That said, real time that would be incredibly difficult to make the right call.

 

[Sheffields Finest]

It isn't about being a contact or no contact sport, one player there has a straight leg and studs showing at waste height. I can buy no red card, I could just about at a push support no caution, but it is at an absolute minimum a foul. As I've said a few times recently, we aren't in the 1980s any more ..!

That said, real time that would be incredibly difficult to make the right call.

I agree, but no call is also an option here, I guarantee most players will see this as play on. A few would see a foul, hardly any would see any red... stop looking for stuff that isn’t that bad!

 

[Ciley Myrus]

I agree, but no call is also an option here, I guarantee most players will see this as play on. A few would see a foul, hardly any would see any red... stop looking for stuff that isn’t that bad!

There is a foul tho!
One has kicked the ball, the other has kicked the guy who kicked the ball!!

 

[Big Cat]

I've consistently said that I want to be confident when issuing a card
This approach has worked well for me over my first two years. Likely in real time, this 'coming-together' falls into the doubt category, so the ink in my pen would not be depleted and football would get what it expects; a foul
And there's a good chance I'd get marked down for it, but hey ho

 

[Sheffields Finest]

There is a foul tho!
One has kicked the ball, the other has kicked the guy who kicked the ball!!

Yes, I get that, but at match speed who did, no-one!

 

[JamesL]

Yes, I get that, but at match speed who did, no-one!

The referee on the day did. He blows his whistle at the end of the clip. I'd like to think I would spot it in my game.

 

[Ciley Myrus]

Yes, I get that, but at match speed who did, no-one!

Me? My first post on it was, free kick no card
Just give a (relucant) free kick and move on!!

 

[Sheffields Finest]

There are coming togethers of feet all over the pitch, just because its twin raised feet you all lose your minds...I get that it may be a foul, I don't get any form of card though....

 

[spuddy1878]

It isn't about being a contact or no contact sport, one player there has a straight leg and studs showing at waste height. I can buy no red card, I could just about at a push support no caution, but it is at an absolute minimum a foul. As I've said a few times recently, we aren't in the 1980s any more ..!

That said, real time that would be incredibly difficult to make the right call.

So does the other fella.

For me the fact that both players are committing similar offences (granted one makes contact) is why im letting it go. if you wave play on there i dont think you're getting many complaints, you would get more complaints if you stopped it.

 

[RustyRef]

So does the other fella.

For me the fact that both players are committing similar offences (granted one makes contact) is why im letting it go. if you wave play on there i dont think you're getting many complaints, you would get more complaints if you stopped it.

Yes, but his leg is bent and his studs are pointing down not towards the opponent. Chalk and cheese there.

 

[Big Cat]

but his leg is bent and his studs are pointing down

By chance? I'd assert that neither player would have premeditated their foot position

 

[spuddy1878]

Yes, but his leg is bent and his studs are pointing down not towards the opponent. Chalk and cheese there.

A bent leg as far as im aware isnt mentioned in any LOTG.

 

[GraemeS]

By chance? I'd assert that neither player would have premeditated their foot position

Why not? There are safe and unsafe ways to tackle at ground level or sliding, why can we not also accept that there are more and less safe ways to tackle at hip height as well?