Real v Arsenal
- Thread starter es1
- Start date
Donate to RefChat
Help keep RefChat running, any donation would be appreciated
Well it needed it
Hard to argue the first isn't a foul. Though totally at odds with anything else given anywhere in Europe all season
I can't believe VAR got involved with the first penalty.
The second one, am I correct in thinking it was ruled out for offside?
The second one, am I correct in thinking it was ruled out for offside?
Peter Grove
RefChat Addict
There appeared to be some confusion. The commentators were saying it wasn't ruled out for offside while at the same time, the on-screen graphic was saying it was.
Dale Johnson said uefa said it was for it not being a foul
ladbroke8745
Censorship
I didn't see restart, so I can't comment on that.
I saw the lead up to ref going to monitor, then reports saying no penalty.
So I am speculating as to what happened.
The fact that he started with a dropped ball, based on what others are saying, I'm assuming the "foul" happened before offside offence meaning by overturning it, it is a dropped ball. So he went to the monitor for the foul and not offside as per what others have said (and the screen). But he could have gone to the screen for the offside to determine himself what order it was as the outcome/restart varies for each.
Foul first (given)/offside = pen
Foul first (not given)/offside = dropped ball
Offside first/foul (doesn't matter if foul or not) = IFK.
Game must restart correctly and it falls on the onfield referee to get it right.
Getting it wrong could be bad for officials their credibility and by sending official to screen for any of these scenarios is best outcome.
I saw the lead up to ref going to monitor, then reports saying no penalty.
So I am speculating as to what happened.
The fact that he started with a dropped ball, based on what others are saying, I'm assuming the "foul" happened before offside offence meaning by overturning it, it is a dropped ball. So he went to the monitor for the foul and not offside as per what others have said (and the screen). But he could have gone to the screen for the offside to determine himself what order it was as the outcome/restart varies for each.
Foul first (given)/offside = pen
Foul first (not given)/offside = dropped ball
Offside first/foul (doesn't matter if foul or not) = IFK.
Game must restart correctly and it falls on the onfield referee to get it right.
Getting it wrong could be bad for officials their credibility and by sending official to screen for any of these scenarios is best outcome.
ladbroke8745
Censorship
Also, was Rice yellow rescinded?
Archer
🟨 C1 (BE)
Riceinded.
There was one clip where Real wanted a penalty and the a/r made to go to the A/R penalty position and then went back to the corner area (not the Mbappe incident).
8.00
www.bbc.co.uk
I found that odd to see.
8.00
UEFA Champions League - 2024/25: Knockout Phase: Quarter-Final Second Legs
Gabby Logan introduces highlights and in-depth analysis from the second legs of the Champions League quarter-finals as Arsenal take on Real Madrid in Spain.
www.bbc.co.uk
I found that odd to see.
No change in Rudigers movement as he stumbles through. Possibility he knew what he was doing but it's certainly not an obvious enough deliberate movement for a review.
Ever found yourself in a situation where the pressure gets to you?
Where no matter what you do, it gets worse and everything goes wrong and you just can’t recover it?
Now imagine that in front of thousands of people and TV cameras.
That’s what’s happened here. He’ll be all the better for it once he’s cleared his head.
Where no matter what you do, it gets worse and everything goes wrong and you just can’t recover it?
Now imagine that in front of thousands of people and TV cameras.
That’s what’s happened here. He’ll be all the better for it once he’s cleared his head.