Must be Tenants SUPERAnd now with added diagrams.
Must be Tenants SUPERAnd now with added diagrams.
@Ciley Myrus do you genuinely believe this or are you too stubborn to admit you were wrong? A couple of weeks ago you were praising the non-advantage and subsequent DOGSO Attwell played in the Swansea game - that even was further out than this...there was one the other day where the player was through but taken down on the edge of the penalty area, further out. This is more central than most
Cant be wrong on a referee opinion call.
Can have different opinions on it, but as those going red cant be wrong, neither can those going yellow
In my opinion, too far from goal, not central, not convinced would have got ball, my opinion, yellow
Was Atwells not 40 yards from goal, if not closer, or am I thinking of another one? I really cant recall the incident being in the other half of the field of play!
Why is where the goal posts are relevant to any argument about Dogso? Where does it say the ball must be heading towards the goal? The LOTG state "general direction of play". In this case the general direction of play is towards the opponents goal.. Not heading away from it. Not going backwards. But advancing on the opponents goal.. The mere fact that you've drawn this imaginary force field between the posts where Dogso can only be committed within is not in keeping with the considerations for Dogso imo.Take the centre spot. And imagine a line 4 yards to the left, and four yards to the right of it. You now have your, headed to the goal
Bear in mind, the centre circle extends to 10 yards, so, your 4 yards (the goal) falls well inside this
Now take the ball, its nowhere near the line you have just drawn. Its prob, 12 yards wide, of, heading to goal
Unless we are confusing heading to goal with, heading to the goal area.
Its not going to, under its own steam, but if the ball was allowed to roll and roll, it would run 12/14 yards from the goal frame
For it to be headed to the goal (and not the goal area), the ball would be in the centre circle, four yards one side, or four yards the other, ( making 8, the width of the goal frame)..
The ball is not even in the centre circle, far less within that 8 yard target.
View attachment 3419
My one remaining memory from this thread is that @Ciley Myrus is now only allowed crayons!!! Probably for the better really!!!
He won't. He doesn't comment on match incidents.Suppose Mr E could clear it up
Why does it need to be central? I understand that would be the case on the edge of the area, but the further away from goal the less this matters..Yes, the point being though that you seem fixated on this notion that the ball is too wide when there are a lot of DOGSO calls correctly given when the ball is wider
Why does it need to be central? I understand that would be the case on the edge of the area, but the further away from goal the less this matters..
Quoted the wrong post @alexgr .....fat finger excuse....Yes, that's the point I'm making - I agree with you!
I'm never drinking tea again!Few seasons ago Stuart Atwell got slated for binning Scotf Parker for a DOGSO just inside the attacking half. It was overturned on appeal. The same would have happened here. Still too much to do.
That would have been under the old wording of moving toward the opponent's goal (and was with other defenders around).Few seasons ago Stuart Atwell got slated for binning Scotf Parker for a DOGSO just inside the attacking half. It was overturned on appeal. The same would have happened here. Still too much to do.
And now with added diagrams.