The Ref Stop

Extraordinary Incident Report – Matchday Conduct and Lack of County FA Response

Donate to RefChat

Help keep RefChat running, any donation would be appreciated

PGE

New Member
Prior to the game, I requested that both sets of coaches allocate parents to act as assistant referees (linespersons). I made it clear that their responsibilities would be limited to assisting with offsides and throw-ins only. This was clearly stated before kick-off, and both coaches agreed.


One parent, Parent A, introduced themselves politely, informed me that they were a qualified referee, and agreed to act as linesperson for Team A.


The match itself was hostile and challenging throughout, with several difficult on-field decisions requiring my intervention. At one point in the first half, I spoke directly with the Team B captain regarding their team’s language and attitude towards me. I also awarded a penalty to Team A for contact, which was contested by Team B players. This brought the score to 1–1, though the tension eased somewhat when Team B quickly regained the lead, making it 1–2.


In the second half, during a goalmouth scramble, I judged from my position that the ball had crossed the line and awarded a goal to Team B. At this point, Parent A (the Team A linesperson) shouted aggressively at me, stating:


“You are an absolute disgrace, that was not a goal, you have no idea what you are doing, look what you have done,”

before throwing their flag to the ground.


This behaviour significantly disrupted the match, undermined my authority as the referee, and led to hostility from players, coaches, parents, and spectators. I felt genuinely threatened and concerned for my safety.


I refused to restart play until Team A appointed a replacement linesperson, which they eventually did. However, both coaches, Coach A and Coach B, continued to treat me with disrespect, with Coach A in particular behaving in an aggressive manner.


As a new referee, this incident was extremely discouraging and left me questioning my future involvement. However, I was reassured after officiating a well-conducted match the following day in another local women’s league, which restored some confidence in my refereeing.


I have since submitted an extraordinary incident report through the refereeing portal, but I have not received any acknowledgement, support, or follow-up from my County FA regarding this matter.
 
The Ref Stop
Good on you for submitting the report, can be especially hard as a new ref to do

Can I ask when the game happened?
 
Prior to the game, I requested that both sets of coaches allocate parents to act as assistant referees (linespersons). I made it clear that their responsibilities would be limited to assisting with offsides and throw-ins only. This was clearly stated before kick-off, and both coaches agreed.


One parent, Parent A, introduced themselves politely, informed me that they were a qualified referee, and agreed to act as linesperson for Team A.


The match itself was hostile and challenging throughout, with several difficult on-field decisions requiring my intervention. At one point in the first half, I spoke directly with the Team B captain regarding their team’s language and attitude towards me. I also awarded a penalty to Team A for contact, which was contested by Team B players. This brought the score to 1–1, though the tension eased somewhat when Team B quickly regained the lead, making it 1–2.


In the second half, during a goalmouth scramble, I judged from my position that the ball had crossed the line and awarded a goal to Team B. At this point, Parent A (the Team A linesperson) shouted aggressively at me, stating:




before throwing their flag to the ground.


This behaviour significantly disrupted the match, undermined my authority as the referee, and led to hostility from players, coaches, parents, and spectators. I felt genuinely threatened and concerned for my safety.


I refused to restart play until Team A appointed a replacement linesperson, which they eventually did. However, both coaches, Coach A and Coach B, continued to treat me with disrespect, with Coach A in particular behaving in an aggressive manner.


As a new referee, this incident was extremely discouraging and left me questioning my future involvement. However, I was reassured after officiating a well-conducted match the following day in another local women’s league, which restored some confidence in my refereeing.


I have since submitted an extraordinary incident report through the refereeing portal, but I have not received any acknowledgement, support, or follow-up from my County FA regarding this matter.
Whilst it would have been appropriate for your County FA to have acknowledged your report, many County FA’s are under-resourced and perhaps inundated with EIO reports. In any event, they may just deal with what is stated within your report with the 2 clubs concerned & therefore, you may only hear if they are charged and wish to appeal etc. In the meantime, you did your job on the day & the appropriate paperwork, so onwards & upwards which you did the following day & hopefully since.
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't necessarily expect a CFA to get in touch with you because you have submitted an extraordinary incident report, it will just be processed and you'd only be contacted if there was a query or appeal. They probably receive hundreds of these every weekend, depending on the size of the county, and wouldn't be practical to contact everyone.

What exactly was the extraordinary incident for? Was it for the CAR throwing your flag to the ground or the general disrespect of the coaches? If the latter there isn't really a lot they can do with the report if you haven't at least cautioned the coaches, an extraordinary incident is only designed for events and situations that aren't covered by standard yellow and red cards.

Of course there is the question of support for a new referee, but RDOs probably won't even be aware of extraordinary incidents as they will go to the discipline department, and in turn they won't know the referee who submitted it is new.
 
Last edited:
Unfortunately the lack of resources mean you won’t be contacted about ERs very often. I’ve submitted around 6 or 7 iirc in 2 and a half years, and the only time I was contacted was when I was the subject of discriminatory abuse.
 
Prior to the game, I requested that both sets of coaches allocate parents to act as assistant referees (linespersons). I made it clear that their responsibilities would be limited to assisting with offsides and throw-ins only. This was clearly stated before kick-off, and both coaches agreed.


One parent, Parent A, introduced themselves politely, informed me that they were a qualified referee, and agreed to act as linesperson for Team A.


The match itself was hostile and challenging throughout, with several difficult on-field decisions requiring my intervention. At one point in the first half, I spoke directly with the Team B captain regarding their team’s language and attitude towards me. I also awarded a penalty to Team A for contact, which was contested by Team B players. This brought the score to 1–1, though the tension eased somewhat when Team B quickly regained the lead, making it 1–2.


In the second half, during a goalmouth scramble, I judged from my position that the ball had crossed the line and awarded a goal to Team B. At this point, Parent A (the Team A linesperson) shouted aggressively at me, stating:




before throwing their flag to the ground.


This behaviour significantly disrupted the match, undermined my authority as the referee, and led to hostility from players, coaches, parents, and spectators. I felt genuinely threatened and concerned for my safety.


I refused to restart play until Team A appointed a replacement linesperson, which they eventually did. However, both coaches, Coach A and Coach B,

Unfortunately the lack of resources mean you won’t be contacted about ERs very often. I’ve submitted around 6 or 7 iirc in 2 and a half years, and the only time I was contacted was when I was the subject of discriminatory abuse.
And presumably if you wanted any support etc you would have approached your RDO or experienced colleagues you knew/respected ?
 
And presumably if you wanted any support etc you would have approached your RDO or experienced colleagues you knew/respected ?
100%. Although on that occasion I must admit they were good with it and I didn’t need to contact them as I had a phone call and email first thing the next morning.
 
Remember a lot of the discipline work now is done centrally for the County FA's by a 3rd party. Your county may not have been made aware of the incident yet. If you can I would send a coopy of the report over to your RDO/County discipline officer, this may be the 1st time they have seen the incident.
 
Remember a lot of the discipline work now is done centrally for the County FA's by a 3rd party. Your county may not have been made aware of the incident yet. If you can I would send a coopy of the report over to your RDO/County discipline officer, this may be the 1st time they have seen the incident.
☝️☝️☝️

From the Birmingham FA website:

All discipline is now managed by Sport Integrity Matters (SIM). For any discipline queries, please contact:
Jemma Edwards - Independent Advisor to Birmingham FA (SIM)
E:
Discipline@BirminghamFA.com
M: 07415 063127
 
Around 15 CFAs have outsourced discipline to Sport Integrity Matters, which is run by the FA's former head of discipline Mark Ives. I suspect they will have processes to let the CFA know if there is a serious report, such as a referee assault, but can't see them flagging up a report for a lack of respect and throwing a flag to the floor.

If you are with one of those counties and you need support probably best to contact your RDO, arguably the same for counties that still have their own discipline departments as there is no guarantee they will let the refereeing department know about reports they receive.
 
As an appointment secretary and league administrator, these things just don’t get made to our attention through that system anymore.

I hope you had someone you could just drop a text to, ask em if they’re free for a chat, and do it that way. Your appts guy, a coach, RDO etc.

We’re pretty close-knit here in my county but there’s so many things which are a surprise when someone mentions them a month later and everyone wishes they’d known.

I’m absolutely not putting this on you, because it’s the system that’s crap and there’s not enough people to support and check-in, but people simply won’t know if it’s… not being harsh… just a bit of aggro.

Counties and competitions should do more to signpost support to their officials, and I’ve taken that on board for my next panel-wide email going out in 3…2…1…
 
Back
Top