one
RefChat Addict
This topic has been discussed a few times but not with a perfect video example like this.
These situations are so hard to judge.
Play advantage and a goal is scored you're great.
Play it and they fluff it up all of a sudden they don't want advantage and you're the worst.
For me there is still a clear opportunity for a goal, my guess is referee is too central and also there is potential a 2nd foul on the attacking player so he wants to jump on the whistle. I'd like to play advantage here and allow a goal. That is what football is about. Goals.
One noticeable point is 17 mins played... Anyone changing their approach based on time in match?
I'd be the other way. 17 mins more likely to stop and send off as playing 73 minutes against 10 is better than sending off with 3 mins plus however much stoppage I'd be more inclined to take the risk here and see how it plays outOn this one I be more inclined to see how things develop.
if its 2-2 on 87 mins I can understand no risks and stopping for the red card.
that said, easy for us sitting watching the clip but i would like to think both times I be waiting to see.
I'd be the other way. 17 mins more likely to stop and send off as playing 73 minutes against 10 is better than sending off with 3 mins plus however much stoppage I'd be more inclined to take the risk here and see how it plays out
But you wouldn't be preventing a. Goal you are actively trying to see if they can get one...My thinking is, prevent a goal on 87 at 2-2 then all the cliches come out, you cost us the game etc.. at 2-2 on 87 mins it really has to be 100% next phase a goal .
I had a momentary thought on that but I think he might also foul him so yes still in dogso land for me.Are we definitely in agreement that’s even DOGSO? That first touch from the attacker is horrendous, taken him almost at a 45 degree angle away from goal with no guarantee he’s keeping the ball after as the defender ends up between attacker and the ball following the touch.
What a ball from midfield though!
On the replay, did the keeper actually touch the attacker? Did the attacker have an awful touch and ran across the defender? On the replay I'd be inclined to say no foul, play on
I know the keeper and players accepted it, just couldn’t see contact