A&H

Colour Clash / Penaties

T

The Daddy

New Member
Can someone explain to me why we, at grassroots level are constantly reminded by local FA`s , assessors etc.... to uphold the laws of the game. Which we practically all do - So answer me this.

1, Why do I see some many Premier League goalkeepers wearing the same colours as the referee - Every week I see this on MOTD.

2. Why is it we give penalties for pushing shoving, shirt pulling, arms round body,shoulders or neck- when waiting for a corner or free kick to come into the penalty area. EPL referees seem to `see` and blow for the same action and award a DFK outside the box...But strangely enough they don`t `see` it as a foul inside the box....so what is the difference..?? Don`t tell me its to do with angles.......a foul is a foul wherever it happens..!!

I get fed up at games when players ask and tell me what they see on MOTD and why don`t I do / do not, do the same. They then say is the PL and PL referees a law unto themselves...at the moment my professionalism stops me from answering that.!!
 
Last edited:
The Referee Store
Those are the unfathomable questions within the polite refereeing society we live.
Others just reckon they referee for club marks.......I know which I think........
 
1. It is a lot different to grass roots as teams can wear black. Sometimes there is no possible colour that the referee can wear that won't clash with a keeper. Like it or not money talks, clubs have to wear their normal kit due to sponsorship reasons, so referees are told to not worry if they clash with a keeper. Not perfect but dies it really matter? When do you ever see the keeper stood next to the referee in open play?

2. I sincerely hope you don't award penalties for pushing, shoving, or any other offence, whilst waiting for free kicks or corners to be taken.
 
1. This is a situation where I think the Laws are a little inconsistent. Law 4 says that the goalkeepers must wear colours that distinguish them from both the other players and the match officials - but then goes on to say that if there's a colour clash between the keepers, the game can still go ahead. One might ask why the same principle could not be applied to a colour clash between a keeper and the referee. As the old saying goes, "What's sauce for the goose ....."

I think it could also be seen as applying the principle, now stated in the Laws, that: "Referees are expected to use common sense and to apply the ‘spirit of the game’ when applying the Laws of the Game, especially when making decisions relating to whether a match takes place and/or continues." [Emphasis mine]

2. See RustyRef's comment.
 
Last edited:
To the OP, just do your game in accordance with law and no one can criticise you. If players give you grief over your enforcement of law, then enforce it a little more by cautioning them for dissent.

Don't worry about what the tv referees are doing until you are one.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top