R
I think you have to give the penalty but I think you can argue that the position of the other defender creates enough doubt about Dogso.If you give a pen for that, and it is soft, then it has to be a red because he’s not attempted to play the ball.
Just added another option to the poll as I'm not convinced its in the box. Nigh on impossible for the on-field referee to have seen this though
View attachment 6963
agree on the AR—he’s the only view available that would be able to tell if the hold continued into the PA or not. Looks very close to me from the angle we have.That is exactly the situation where you would expect the info from the active AR.
I don't think it's enough for a foul, there's not enough impact, but once given DFK + RC should be the outcome.
If it was a penalty, I think this falls somewhere on the borderline that the new "challenge" for the ball law change that came in this year. I think the still is damning and makes it a red but totally different to give it in real time.
I think you're being a tad generous to say the pulling continues into the area. The defender has already let go by this pointI think it starts outside the area but continues into it, so if you are giving it then it has to be a penalty and red card. It would be very much on the soft side though.
Telling. Video review is a cruel mistress.Just added another option to the poll as I'm not convinced its in the box. Nigh on impossible for the on-field referee to have seen this though
View attachment 6963
I see what you are saying but I think you are overstating the contact. But that's football, game of opinions.i don’t agree that it isn’t a foul—you can see the pull shift his torso back Which is definitely enough to take someone off balance when running at speed. I do agree that it is easy DOGSO once there is a foul. The other defender behind the attacker can’t change that.
Yes, it is.Telling. Video review is a cruel mistress.
Think that depends where his left shoulder is, there's an argument to say it is on the line which would obviously be in the area. Only the AR would be able to judge that though, and he probably can't see the slight pull through the player's body.I think you're being a tad generous to say the pulling continues into the area. The defender has already let go by this point
Bloody hell Rusty, I'd have loved you observing me. You're clearly a referees observerThink that depends where his left shoulder is, there's an argument to say it is on the line which would obviously be in the area. Only the AR would be able to judge that though, and he probably can't see the slight pull through the player's body.
View attachment 6965
Maybe it was @JamesL doing one of his 30kmph turbo sprintsRef must've in a decent sprint after giving it, from the build-up looks like he would've been just leaving the centre circle.
He can only achieve that when wearing his smart watch. . .Maybe it was @JamesL doing one of his 30kmph turbo sprints
Got to make up for the poor positioning, somehowMaybe it was @JamesL doing one of his 30kmph turbo sprints