santa sangria
RefChat Addict
Vicario wipes out the attacker after a through ball. 87 mins. Attacker has got there first. Ball is still in play in the air at the foul. Obvious penalty for me. Vicario late, foul, easy… but nothing…
But it should be given... It is a failing of the Professional game to ignore foul play after 'getting the shot away'. The ball was clearly still on the FOPSo you're going to use the term Spuds and then argue for a PK that is never ever given at the professional level.
But it's hard to take the post seriously on a neutral ref forum when the thread title uses the term for the club from the fan forums for Arsenal and Chelsea. The thread title itself already sounds of bias.But it should be given... It is a failing of the Professional game to ignore foul play after 'getting the shot away'. The ball was clearly still on the FOP
This 'expectation' needs to be changed because it is wrong
Sorry. I didn’t mean it to be pejorative.But it's hard to take the post seriously on a neutral ref forum when the thread title uses the term for the club from the fan forums for Arsenal and Chelsea. The thread title itself already sounds of bias.
Pickford on VVD was an assault, this one was just a slightly late tackle.If you have some clips from major tournaments in the VAR era where this foul is not giving, would be interesting to see.
Pickford on VVD springs to mind. And I thought the consensus there was it was an obvious foul and a miss from the officials.
I don't think anyone suggested sending the keeper off?The players never even considered it a pen. I haven't see anything that suggested Frank did. The goal kick was only delayed so they could complete a check for a possible handball a little earlier. If you're giving a PK and sending the keeper off there then good luck the rest of the match and your career. I'm not saying in theory the GK shouldn't be punished but it can't just be one ref going against years of consistent standards.
just seen it. penalty for me.Vicario wipes out the attacker after a through ball. 87 mins. Attacker has got there first. Ball is still in play in the air at the foul. Obvious penalty for me. Vicario late, foul, easy… but nothing…
Yeah, I think you're seeing comments that aren't there. A red card here would be absolutely wrong in law, as the ball is already going out of play before anyone else has a chance to influence it, and the force doesn't rise to SFP.The players never even considered it a pen. I haven't see anything that suggested Frank did. The goal kick was only delayed so they could complete a check for a possible handball a little earlier. If you're giving a PK and sending the keeper off there then good luck the rest of the match and your career. I'm not saying in theory the GK shouldn't be punished but it can't just be one ref going against years of consistent standards.
Yeah, I think you're seeing comments that aren't there. A red card here would be absolutely wrong in law, as the ball is already going out of play before anyone else has a chance to influence it, and the force doesn't rise to SFP.
But a penalty and maybe (but probably not) a yellow card would have been a far better decision than no foul.
I think there are a couple of factors that lead us there. One is that GKs are expected to throe their bodies in harms way And risk injury. So they get a bit of slack. Alas, I think too often they get too much slack.If a player follows through on another player anywhere else on the pitch like that.... It's a foul and probably a caution.
Why are keepers protected and essentially allowed to foul players without consequences?