one
RefChat Addict
I beg to differ. Even if believe what the law says means "arm being out", it is usually an offence not always. It is not criteria, just a consideration. I do agree with your second paragraph though.Under the current handball law that is an offence. His arms are out, it hasn't deflected off his body, so the expectation is that it is a handling offence.
Something else no one discussed, even if you believe this is a deliberate handball, was it a clear and obvious error by the referee for it to be reviewed? Given the debate here, i'd say obviously its not obvious.