A match incident hypothetical question

[CallumRushton13]

Ok second defender DOGSO, penalty + red easy, but :
Is the foul committed by the keeper careless, reckless or with excessive force ? IMO you can't caution a player for a DOGSO-ish foul, it's either DOGSO or no DOGSO. If the striker would have scored, would you've cautioned the GK ?

Don't know if I made myself clear here

Foul tackle breaking up a promising attack would fit the bill