The Ref Stop

Search results

  1. R

    England Vs Croatia

    I don't think this is an egregious case of someone not looking at the ball just wrestling their opponent though. The defender was looking at ball, not Quansah. Yes there was minor and brief holding, but unless you're going to have zero tolerance for holding (fine, but we're a long way from that)...
  2. R

    England Vs Croatia

    Was a little surprised it was given to be honest, as I don’t think it was a sustained hold that impacted Quansah’s ability to challenge for the ball. Had Quansah not thrown himself to the ground, I doubt we get it, which means we’re effectively rewarding him for doing so. But I suppose the...
  3. R

    Man Utd v Villa

    I do think it should be added to law, but as I've said elsewhere, it needs to be done in a careful way so that we don't end up with situation where players are deliberately running in to referees if they might be struggling to make it to their opponent in a bid to get the game stopped.
  4. R

    Man Utd v Villa

    With regards to the 'foul' on the keeper... with all current interpretation / guidance, it's just not a foul... but it feels like it should be. To clarify, the action by Lamens had no material impact on Suzuki's ability to complete the action he attempted (punching the ball). Not a foul for me...
  5. R

    Cray v Stockport

    I didn't watch the game, but I am pleased to hear that Stockport's replacement keeper conceded the free kick after seeing his ridiculous shin pads all over social media (and how un-rushed he was in getting ready)
  6. R

    VAR added time

    The guidance from ProRef is the same as the guidance from the FA.
  7. R

    VAR added time

    This game was in England and our guidance on what we allow for involves time for red cards, but not cautions. (Note I said 'in isolation' because if for whatever reason the caution process takes a long time, we can still add that time under making allowance for match events of delays etc)
  8. R

    Blackburn Stoke

    I'm more concerned about the fact I was convinced we'd gone back 15 years and Morten Gamst Pedersen was back - what a player!
  9. R

    VAR added time

    Really slow on this, just catching up, but worth pointing out time for cautions shouldn't be included in added time calculations in isolation.
  10. R

    New LoTG - Injuries - Liking it!!

    I think what IFAB have suggested is the correct / best outcome. The opportunities rule was brought in because lots of subs slows down the game. If the game is stopped by a team for a sub, why should that team gain the opportunity to do that again just because the player in question refuses to...
  11. R

    FA Interviews for grassroots referees

    As long as it's the top half then happy days - wouldn't want the bottom half as they only last a few matches.
  12. R

    Player pacing out the wall - Dissent or Delaying?

    As you say, players count, so I think it's always a good idea to try and do 10 steps and make that the 10 yards. I remember Dermot (I think) on that set up segment on SSN say that for him 11 steps is 10 yards, but I don't think you help yourself by doing 11 steps as expectation is 1 step = 1...
  13. R

    IFAB changes for 26-27

    Great news, personally couldn’t care less about how the game plans out tactically, I just think this is a nightmare for ARs trying to make accurate judgments
  14. R

    Liverpool - Man C

    Arguably that’s worse 😉
  15. R

    Goalkeeper handball

    No I agree, was just pointing out that it's there if there is a situation where the keeper carries the ball outside.
  16. R

    Goalkeeper handball

    If a goalkeeper carries a ball outside the box then he can't be sanctioned for DOGSO or SPA (not certain where that is in the book, but I know it's there somewhere) Don't think that applies here, and a caution is a very odd decision.
  17. R

    Lincoln - West Ham

    Tom Hamer saw red after just 160 seconds for a reckless challenge on Joel Veltman Taken from the BBC's match report :facepalm:
  18. R

    Sunderland v Brighton DOGSO

    If I remember rightly, the referee didn't give a foul on field did he? Had he given a foul and a caution I think VAR would have found it a lot easier not to get involved, but as no foul was given it made it trickier.
  19. R

    Open Age Abandoned

    Yeah that is a valid point tbf, hadn’t really taken the red card context in to account, albeit he did take the unusual step of apologising after being sent off
  20. R

    Open Age Abandoned

    Controversial opinion incoming... The way I read the opening post... there wasn't long left in the match and the man sent off wasn't causing you any issues. My personal opinion is that it was probably unnecessary to ask him to leave. With that said, you didn't do anything wrong and the league...
Back
Top