The Ref Stop

Search results

  1. B

    Arsenal Vs Hull

    I hadn’t seen either decision until I just looked them up because of this post! Are you giving either? I can see why he’s given both but do you think he’s right? I think he is but also don’t know if I would be brave enough to give them?
  2. B

    Everton vs Chelsea - 2nd goal

    No skin in the game as they say but I’ve just watched the highlights from the weekend - surprised there are no comments about the second free kick - is the Chelsea attacking ‘wall’ a bit close to Everton’s? Could be the camera angle but surely they’re closer than 1 yard?
  3. B

    Does football/ do referees need to fight back or is it all too far gone?

    Hi all, I ask this knowing the answer, but maybe the older referees will give more context and explain - how and when did it become acceptable for players to say whatever they like with no real repercussions, from grassroots to the Premier League! In the PL just today, Fernandes for Man Utd was...
  4. B

    Brentford v Liverpool VAR overrule

    I know he only has a few seconds and it’s hard to go in to detail with the decision while everyone is looking at you, but on the mic he says “After review, the Brentford player plays the ball, final decision dropped ball” Pedantic from me but you can see why fans/ players then shout “he got the...
  5. B

    Man Utd v Tottenham

    Was Shaw running 20 yards to push someone square in the chest not a violent act? Excessive force when not challenging for ball? I’d say yes and it should be a red card - but for some reason isn’t! If I was playing and had to face a 2 handed shove to my chest from someone with a running start or...
  6. B

    Finland vs Albania non penalty

    I’m just glad you’ve said it should have been a penalty - nothing special about the clip but as it was waved away by the referee and the VAR I thought I was missing something!
  7. B

    Finland vs Albania non penalty

    Hi all, I’ve just come across this decision from the weekend and it’s one of those where it makes me question if I actually know what I am doing or not! Albania player not awarded a penalty and actually cautioned for simulation, which the VAR upheld. Is it a penalty? I’d say 9/10 yes but with...
  8. B

    Delaying goal kicks ..

    After the 3rd/ 4th time could you give a caution for persistent offending? Similar to 8 second count from hands?
  9. B

    Ball hitting the referee

    One in particular from Michael Oliver really annoyed me, hit him and the ball went backwards about 20 yards to Martinez, no promising attack, no change of possession etc etc, and yet the game was still stopped. As you say, a lot of the players stopped anyway as they are expecting a dropped ball...
  10. B

    Crewe goal

    Interesting he said that, and it just goes to show how split everyone is on it, as I spoke with two current EFL officials and they suspected that this goal would definitely be included in their weekly meeting and clip session, with the expectation it should be disallowed!! But they were speaking...
  11. B

    Field conditions - dry weather

    This - and any slide tackle or trip resulting in a huge graze all along the leg that will never heal!
  12. B

    West Brom 2 game ban for handball

    Where does it end?? A player appeals for a corner even though it was obviously a goal kick, the referee gives the corner, the team score from the corner, are they going to ban the player who wrongly won the corner? Ridiculous decision to ban him if you ask me! (Which no one did!!)
  13. B

    Young ref and a shirtless club lino call an offside then give a "deadball" goal

    Fair play! There is no way if I am following the game I could also judge offside - I have an idea if someone is off or on obviously but there is no way I could fairly and accurately say so especially when they are close.
  14. B

    What’s the right call here?

    Good decision
  15. B

    New LoTG - Injuries - Liking it!!

    “An injured player may not be treated on the field of play and, where an injury results in play being stopped or the restart of play being delayed, the injured player must leave the field of play and may only re-enter one minute after play has restarted;” Bit of a grey area because if you pause...
  16. B

    Whistle blast before 5 second count down.

    Could have been the same meeting, I was going to say something but didn’t want to rock the boat and cause a scene! That was wrong information to a room of 90 people!!
  17. B

    Whistle blast before 5 second count down.

    I went to an RA meeting last night and a question from someone was something along the lines of “what happens if a player picks the ball up for a throw in and then puts it down for the next player to come and take” - The answer from someone in the room and then confirmed by an RDO was “you...
  18. B

    France - Spain

    Someone explain that Dembele freekick/ non freekick then! They’re just making it up as they go along! I have stuck up for all referees and all decisions this World Cup but this one has really got to me - it’s not even that important but it’s the one that’s made me realise that we may be obsolete...
  19. B

    Ecuador v Germany

    I am seeing people genuinely suggest that because the player 'headed' the foot it isn't a foul - in slow motion it may look that way but in full speed he has gone to head the ball and the strikers leg gets there first, therefore risking injury and therefore causing dangerous play - the fact...
  20. B

    England v Ghana

    Found this - think the injuries were classed as serious
Back
Top