The Ref Stop

Search results

  1. JamesL

    Man Utd vs Man City

    I think this is a mistake too. Fernandez attempts to play a ball that's close which impacts an opponent (2 in fact both Martinez and the GK.)
  2. JamesL

    Verbal distraction inside the box???

    C1 BE but the OP already knows that 😝 Edit: Also on reflection potential/probable dogso red card instead.
  3. JamesL

    Verbal distraction inside the box???

    If you are going to penalise the offence it would be an indirect free kick.
  4. JamesL

    New LoTG - Injuries - Liking it!!

    I don't think there's any scenario where the minute transfers to another player. They are independent issues. I've found that the 1 minute is working and the injuries and physio coming on is much less. But then the players who are genuinely injured are almost paying the price for the sins of...
  5. JamesL

    New LoTG - Injuries - Liking it!!

    There is an exemption if it's an injured player that's being subbed off. "The referee may decide not to apply the ten-second time limit, including when: a player’s injury clearly prevents them from leaving the field within that time"
  6. JamesL

    West Brom 2 game ban for handball

    Not the same thing though, is it?
  7. JamesL

    60+ assistant referee

    Roger east was mid- late 50s in the PL I think. If you are good enough age isn't a barrier.
  8. JamesL

    Dealing with sweaty match cards and notepad

    Collecting the fines as well are ya?
  9. JamesL

    Whistle blast before 5 second count down.

    I think the punishment helps. Reversing the restart instead of caution or idfk in what is a flipping mess to manage at times let's face it, will probably allow it to maintain. Similar to the GK holding the ball, that seems to be holding well.
  10. JamesL

    Maguire hb yay or nay

    It wasn't but there was also the imminent threat of the opponents boot..I think anyone going into that challenge instinctively (i.e. reflex) defends them self in that way.
  11. JamesL

    Maguire hb yay or nay

    Ifab, at least in 2022, would disagree with your take on that.
  12. JamesL

    Maguire hb yay or nay

    It's a reflex action. He's about to potentially get thumped in the chest area by the ball or opponent boot. No way your arms do anything other than that in that situation.
  13. JamesL

    Leeds v Brentford

    Looks a clear pen to me. Only thing I think is that the player has gone down very easy. And I think that maybe sways it on motivation of attacker. That said the action of defender is careless so it's a penalty kick outcome for me.
  14. JamesL

    Maguire hb yay or nay

    Deliberate handball - no Made body unnaturally bigger - no Scored immediately in the opponents goal - no No handball offence committed.
  15. JamesL

    Liverpool v Nottm Forest

    There is nothing in law that supports this so if the referee deemed the challenge to be careless, reckless or excessive force then a penalty should be awarded. It's only grey because at some time someone somewhere applied this thinking and it seems to be one of those myths that have stuck, like...
  16. JamesL

    Tape Advice!

    Any reason you haven't just ironed it on?
  17. JamesL

    Damaged goal posts

    Play on.
  18. JamesL

    L4 Assessment Slump

    Realistically at step 3/4 a referee with an average of 72.5 is reclassification fodder. I don't know what the fix is. I think there are some good suggestions here. I expect it will all change again I the future.
  19. JamesL

    L4 Assessment Slump

    It's not far off on the annual. Not worth looking in the first few weeks as takes a bit to settle down
  20. JamesL

    West Brom 2 game ban for handball

    Clarification on how to reasonably react? Gee I don't know, what about some sportsmanship and say no goal, it went in off my arm... Never happen I know!
Back
Top