The Ref Stop

Plymouth vs Peterborough

Donate to RefChat

Help keep RefChat running, any donation would be appreciated

Tim Punter

Level 5 referee
Level 5 Referee
1:40

Genuine LOTG question as just watched this in the EFL highlights, about 1:40min in on the link

Can’t see why this is not a red card. Keeper doesn’t make any attempt. Yes, there is a covering defender, but don’t think that’s enough for it not to be a clear goal scoring opportunity. Thoughts?

 
The Ref Stop
The GK can clearly be seen reaching for the ball. As this is a DOGSO offence that was a challenge for the ball and a penalty kick was awarded the GK cannot be sent off.
 
  • Like
Reactions: one
For me the GK goes for the ball and mises it then, in a second motion, trips the player.

Red card for me.
GK's other arm is protecting himself from the inevitable collision as he knows he is putting himself in the attacker's way while going for the ball. Each frame of this video is 40 milliseconds and in slow-mo I only see 3 or 4 frames after he misses the ball before the collision, there just isn't the time here to have separate actions in my opinion.
 
Fair comments, just want to make sure I make the right decision of this happens in a game I am reffing. Not convinced it was an attempt, as I think he missed the ball and raised hind leg to trip the player. But not clear
 
The Pro Ref expectation there would be penalty and caution. There’s at least some play for the ball, I can’t see any L1 referee going red there.

That was an “attempt to play the ball” only in the world in which we search wildly for excuses not to send off players when a PK is awarded. I think the “right” call here is red. But I, somewhat reluctantly, agree that the expected call is yellow. DOGSO has come a long way from its origin of wiping out cynical fouls. This was a cynical take down by the GK who knew he was never getting the ball. Sadly, out changes in interpretation of DOGSO make it a smart play.
 
That was an “attempt to play the ball” only in the world in which we search wildly for excuses not to send off players when a PK is awarded. I think the “right” call here is red. But I, somewhat reluctantly, agree that the expected call is yellow. DOGSO has come a long way from its origin of wiping out cynical fouls. This was a cynical take down by the GK who knew he was never getting the ball. Sadly, out changes in interpretation of DOGSO make it a smart play.
Yep, agreed. This should definitely be a red
 
Are you saying the referee was correct in law?
I’m saying that Pro Ref only want DOGSO to be given on penalties when it is very obvious there was zero attempt for the ball. I’m not even convinced Elliott Anderson would have seen red had his foul playing for England happened in the EPL.
 
I’m saying that Pro Ref only want DOGSO to be given on penalties when it is very obvious there was zero attempt for the ball. I’m not even convinced Elliott Anderson would have seen red had his foul playing for England happened in the EPL.
I'm not interested in pro-ref. I'm interested in law.
 
I'm not interested in pro-ref. I'm interested in law.
And I was talking about the Pro Ref expectations.

But even at grass roots there’s no way on earth that is incorrect in law, it is just a debatable decision. In my opinion there’s enough there to say the keeper tried to get the ball to make it a supportable caution.
 
Back
Top