The Ref Stop

Everton Vs Coventry - Hair Pulling

Donate to RefChat

Help keep RefChat running, any donation would be appreciated

The Ref Stop
The comical thing is the very same people that complained about red cards for "accidental" hair pulling last season are now bemoaning this not being a red card. People have very short memories, leads back to my point about people saying they don't want VAR, the very second something serious was then missed they'd be demanding technology to help.
 
@RustyRef Don't think that's the case overall, only people who don't know the advice changed are saying it should be a red based on past past precedents.

It can't possibly be a red last season, and now not even careless

The instructions that it was a red card were wrong last season despite some pretty creative interpretations here and elsewhere to support it being a red card.
Not sure who actually brought in that guidance in the first place.
 
Should definitely have been a penalty.
Don't think so, it wouldn't have been a penalty for that level of holding of a shirt, they would say it wasn't sustained enough. So if they are saying that someone accidentally pulling hair when they go to grab a shirt is no longer a red card, I don't really see how it could be a foul either, given it wouldn't be a foul if their actual intention of grabbing the shirt had worked.
 
Don't think so, it wouldn't have been a penalty for that level of holding of a shirt, they would say it wasn't sustained enough. So if they are saying that someone accidentally pulling hair when they go to grab a shirt is no longer a red card, I don't really see how it could be a foul either, given it wouldn't be a foul if their actual intention of grabbing the shirt had worked.
Non-negligible hair pulling should nearly always be a careless challenge in my opinion. I know Pro Ref guidance says differently but that guidance basically gives players licence to do it as much as they like if they are good enough actors to make it look accidental. The only way I think it wouldn't be careless is if the hair unexpectedly flicked in the way.
 
I am going to side track here. A quote from the article re KMI panel.

"But it is more important in the Premier League, with the results creating a merit table which contributes to 50% of referees' salaries in bonus payments."

This is terrible. It creates a conflict of interest with money on the line. Basically referees have to make decisions based on what the KMI panel think is right instead of what they think is right. The two are not always the same.

Makes me think of LOTG quizes I do when sometimes I know the answer I think is right is not the same as the answer the quizzer thinks is right.
 
I guess it depends a lot on what you think of the KMI panel. Referees should be aligning to what is expected of them, and should be rated on missed KMIs. But i have less confidence that the KMI panel is always “right.” And how the rankings really work? Are we really dinging the ref on a 3-2 decision? Or are we really only dinging the ref on unanimous or at least 4-1 decisions? And when it says “contributes” what does that mean? Is it 5% of the the 50% or is it the main contributor to the bonus?
 
I am going to side track here. A quote from the article re KMI panel.

"But it is more important in the Premier League, with the results creating a merit table which contributes to 50% of referees' salaries in bonus payments."

This is terrible. It creates a conflict of interest with money on the line. Basically referees have to make decisions based on what the KMI panel think is right instead of what they think is right. The two are not always the same.

Makes me think of LOTG quizes I do when sometimes I know the answer I think is right is not the same as the answer the quizzer thinks is right.
Agree, it is ludicrous. Take the Thierno Barry goal, 3 of the panel said it should have been disallowed as in all probability it hit his hand. Yet all 5 of them say no VAR intervention was correct as there was no clear evidence it hit his hand. So three of the panel agree there was no evidence it hit his hand but think the referee should be penalised for making the wrong decision. How is the referee supposed to deem it hit the hand when multiple people watching a slow motion video can't see any evidence of it hitting the hand? It is totally nonsensical, and Stuart Attwell's renumeration will be adversely affected for making an incorrect decision.

You really couldn't make that up. 5 people, 4 of which have no qualifications in the laws of football, can rule that a referee made a mistake even though they have no evidence. It is just a pathetic attempt to appease clubs and fans, and in doing so they are chucking the referees under the bus. They need to go back to a qualified observer at the ground who judges the performance, using replay footage for KMDs.
 
@RustyRef Not all footage was available to VAR, they don't get the super zoom that should it hit the arm conclusively as it takes too long to calibrate
Neither does the referee though. And in any case, they voted 5-0 in favour of VAR being correct not to intervene as there was no conclusive evidence that it hit the hand.
 
No conclusive evidence from the "Readily available footage" ie the footage that was available to VAR when they made the decision wasn't conclusive. The zoom footage came later
 
Agree, it is ludicrous. Take the Thierno Barry goal, 3 of the panel said it should have been disallowed as in all probability it hit his hand. Yet all 5 of them say no VAR intervention was correct as there was no clear evidence it hit his hand. So three of the panel agree there was no evidence it hit his hand but think the referee should be penalised for making the wrong decision. How is the referee supposed to deem it hit the hand when multiple people watching a slow motion video can't see any evidence of it hitting the hand? It is totally nonsensical, and Stuart Attwell's renumeration will be adversely affected for making an incorrect decision.

You really couldn't make that up. 5 people, 4 of which have no qualifications in the laws of football, can rule that a referee made a mistake even though they have no evidence. It is just a pathetic attempt to appease clubs and fans, and in doing so they are chucking the referees under the bus. They need to go back to a qualified observer at the ground who judges the performance, using replay footage for KMDs.
Or with regard to your final para at least a KMI panel that has experienced Referees or ex Referees. Of course there would then be cries of cover up, defending your own etc. It’s a no win situation, but at least experience of Laws of the game, rather than ex players/coaches with the benefit of a Pro Ref representative presumably advising them on the Laws of the Game.
 
No conclusive evidence from the "Readily available footage" ie the footage that was available to VAR when they made the decision wasn't conclusive. The zoom footage came later
I'm not really disputing that, rather that it is ridiculous that unqualified people can rule on a decision being correct or not and that having an impact on a match official's renumeration.

Stuart Attwell could only go on one look at it, even when VAR looked at it they had no conclusive evidence. I accept that better evidence may have been found days later through enhancement, but that's no use to either referee or VAR. Would a police officer have their salary docked if they didn't charge someone based on the evidence available to them at the time, only for better evidence to appear at a later date?
 
Or with regard to your final para at least a KMI panel that has experienced Referees or ex Referees. Of course there would then be cries of cover up, defending your own etc. It’s a no win situation, but at least experience of Laws of the game, rather than ex players/coaches with the benefit of a Pro Ref representative presumably advising them on the Laws of the Game.
That's the appeals panel where one ex-referee advises the panel with regards to law. The KMI panel doesn't work like that, it is 4 ex-players / managers and one ex-referee / PGMO member. Pretty sure there is no one to guide to panel members, and from what I read they aren't even in a room together, it is all done in isolation, they are just sent clips and asked to offer their opinions and make their decisions.

Said it before but it is akin to asking ex-criminals to rule on the outcome of court cases on the basis of them having experience of being criminals. They know nothing about the laws, just as ex-footballers have experience of playing but not applying the laws, and let's face it we all know that the majority of players are pig ignorant when it comes to knowing the laws of the game they play in.
 
That's the appeals panel where one ex-referee advises the panel with regards to law. The KMI panel doesn't work like that, it is 4 ex-players / managers and one ex-referee / PGMO member. Pretty sure there is no one to guide to panel members, and from what I read they aren't even in a room together, it is all done in isolation, they are just sent clips and asked to offer their opinions and make their decisions.

Said it before but it is akin to asking ex-criminals to rule on the outcome of court cases on the basis of them having experience of being criminals. They know nothing about the laws, just as ex-footballers have experience of playing but not applying the laws, and let's face it we all know that the majority of players are pig ignorant when it comes to knowing the laws of the game they play in.
In National League North & South the KMI panel was & perhaps still is if in place, ran by ex Referee/Observer/coach/Performance Devevloper. The first sentence of my post was only suggesting that this is how the PL KMI should have perhaps operated & not as it has always been with ex players etc, but then it would not have been deemed ‘independent’.
 
Back
Top