It is in the senior English game, PGMOL have instructed referees that they must caution for it.Consider what Collina said at the world cup. For players, non verbal communication can be Ok, especially in multi language situations.
Inaginary card is not mandatory caution. You must consider the context and decide.
Referees have visited every club and told all players that waving an imaginary card will be a mandatory yellow. If players are still stupid enough to do it then they can't look beyond themselves. There have also been countless cautions for delaying the restart, both in the EPL this weekend and the EFL since it restarted, the message will get through eventually.Difficult to follow. So Collina jnstructed referees basically not to. PGMOL instructed referees to.
Both Jackson and Mac Allister cautioned by Taylor for card waving in the Che Liv game now.
Both cases the players are just asking Taylor why no card. Did not seem like “dissent” at all. Reeks of fixing a problem that didn’t exist.
Mesnwhile players are still standing in front of the ball to delay snd Jackson studs in Konate’s chest just a yellow. Lord.
They're the same thing.So waving an imaginary card is a caution but not shouting "That's a yellow, ref"...
I think that’s why we’re seeing the pro cards for the waving--it’s public. I doubt the pro refs are giving a card for a verbal “that’s a yellow.”I think the difference is that a shout to the ref is only heard on the pitch whereas visibly waving an imaginary card can be seen by all and is viewed as undermining the referee's authority as well as USB.
Absolutely.I think that’s why we’re seeing the pro cards for the waving--it’s public. I doubt the pro refs are giving a card for a verbal “that’s a yellow.”
usb.Digging up an old thread instead of starting a new one, as I was thinking about this very scenario in regards to sin bins.
If sin bins are in play, does waving an imaginary card fall under dissent, and therefore 10 minutes in the bin? or does it fall under USB and is a yellow card?
Please don't dig up old threads, always start a new one.Digging up an old thread instead of starting a new one, as I was thinking about this very scenario in regards to sin bins.
If sin bins are in play, does waving an imaginary card fall under dissent, and therefore 10 minutes in the bin? or does it fall under USB and is a yellow card?