A&H

GraemeS's latest activity

  • GraemeS
    GraemeS replied to the thread WHM v LIV.
    No. I'm dismissive of opinions that are based on nonsense and are attempting to drag the conversation off topic. Note that you're not...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS replied to the thread WHM v LIV.
    The GK was setting up for a free kick. What GK who's team is trying to hold on for a draw does anything else other than collapse to the...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS reacted to Tealeaf's post in the thread Personalised boots ref? with Like Like.
    The first thing that stands out to me is, why is this even a story? Another nonsense, slow-news day social post by Match of the “Duh”...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS replied to the thread Personalised boots ref?.
    I mean, there are two aspects to this. One, @Tealeaf has laid out perfectly. The other is that the possibility this person might...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS replied to the thread WHM v LIV.
    Applied what law? He's already applied the advantage law (arguably incorrectly, because there isn't really a foul), but even if you...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS replied to the thread WHM v LIV.
    Having thought about it, this for me is the bit that's really scandalous. Make an incorrect decision regarding a foul or an injury -...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS reacted to Mooseybaby's post in the thread AVL vs CHE with Like Like.
    It was a shove and surprised it wasn't given in real time by Craig Pawson. However it's just frustrating that VAR has been turning a...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS replied to the thread WHM v LIV.
    The GK never takes a single step - not towards the ball and not sideways to makes a save. Unless Gakpo chooses to hit it directly at a...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS replied to the thread WHM v LIV.
    Come on, be serious. Gakpo was about 5m away from kicking the ball into an empty net before AT incorrectly blew the whistle and invented...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS replied to the thread WHM v LIV.
    A GK standing on his feet, choosing to throw the ball out in front of himself and then fiddle with his socks is not "injured" by any...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS reacted to The Ginger Ref's post in the thread WHM v LIV with Like Like.
    IMO Anthony Taylor and Areola made an absolute howler between them. AT gave an advantage for the challenge on Areola once he had the...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS replied to the thread Goal kick taken in wrong place.
    Off the top of my head.....have you tried reading post 1 in this thread? AR informs the ref the GK should be retaken and the ref chooses...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS reacted to Runner Ref's post in the thread Wolves vs Bournemouth with Like Like.
    This is easily resolved by implementing relevant policies. Only certain situations/incidents can be challenged; similar to VAR They...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS reacted to RustyRef's post in the thread Wolves vs Bournemouth with Like Like.
    They will be even tighter next season. The current system has a margin of error in favour in favour of the attacker, meaning if the...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS reacted to es1's post in the thread Wolves vs Bournemouth with Like Like.
    This is where challenges would work well imo. There's no appeal and no expectation of a foul from anyone on the pitch. A foul is a...
Show older items
Back
Top