GraemeS
Latest activity Postings About
-
-
This is easily resolved by implementing relevant policies. Only certain situations/incidents can be challenged; similar to VAR They...
-
They will be even tighter next season. The current system has a margin of error in favour in favour of the attacker, meaning if the...
-
This is where challenges would work well imo. There's no appeal and no expectation of a foul from anyone on the pitch. A foul is a...
-
GraemeS replied to the thread EVE vs LIV.What I'm reading there is "the improvement wouldn't be perfect, so may as well not bother". Fundamentally disagree. If open audio led...
-
GraemeS replied to the thread Goal kick taken in wrong place.I'm not sure what there is in my post that it's possible to disagree with. Short of pulling a whistle out of their pocket, declaring the...
-
GraemeS replied to the thread Goal kick taken in wrong place.Don't over-fixate on the word "penalise". Anything the AR signals for is technically within the referee's power to disagree with and...
-
GraemeS replied to the thread Everton - Forest.I don't think this is wrong, but also, I don't think it should automatically rule out aiming for consistency and only achieving 90% of...
-
True enough. There is no universe in which the attacking IFK is remotely defensible. (Well, OK, there used to be such a universe . . ...
-
GraemeS replied to the thread Goal kick taken in wrong place.But the AR technically doesn't get to make that decision, they are only recommending a decision. However inadvisedly, the referee can...
-
GraemeS replied to the thread Everton - Forest.I think that is an interesting point. I read Dale Johnson's article most weeks and a reoccurring theme is the idea that VAR isn't...
-
GraemeS replied to the thread Respect handshake.I mean, it absolutely is a bigger/more important question in two ways. 1: It's part of the LOTG, which is higher in the hierarchy of...
-
GraemeS replied to the thread Ghost goals over the decades.That specifically doesn't say they couldn't intervene, only that they didn't. They were perfectly empowered to make the call, they just...
-
GraemeS replied to the thread Respect handshake.The correct answer is: Do what the league rules say to do. In reality - if the teams are walking out of the changing rooms at the start...
-
I always have this in the pre-match: “If I wave you down, it’s a good thing. You give me the information with the flag. If you think the...
-
GraemeS replied to the thread FA Cup Replays Scrapped.There are sensible ways this could have been done, this just isn't it. The concern is obviously gate receipts for a smaller team being...
-
-
Loading…
-
Loading…
