A&H

GraemeS's latest activity

  • GraemeS
    GraemeS reacted to es1's post in the thread FA Cup Replays Scrapped with Like Like.
    really feel the rules should change to say the team in the lower ranked league can choose to play home or away as a result. if the same...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS replied to the thread Open Age Overturning AR decision.
    Agree with Santa - phrasing this as a "disagreement" with your AR is needlessly confrontational and dismissive. They have part of the...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS replied to the thread Everton - Forest.
    I think you can find one this past weekend in the United Coventry semi-final.
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS reacted to RefereeX's post in the thread Open Age Overturning AR decision with Like Like.
    I presume the play by the defender constitutes a deliberate play in law? One thing I would say is that in this situation, if it leads...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS reacted to OnlyUseMeWhistle's post in the thread Karl Henry with Like Like.
    I do think the context of the victim being 15 should lower the bar for intimidation. An adult man shouting at you, coming onto the pitch...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS reacted to Runner Ref's post in the thread Advice to ARs on Penalties. with Like Like.
    Pretty much same as above, with the addition of a number 4 4) There's a foul/handball, I see it, I blow. But I don't know if it's in or...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS reacted to Runner Ref's post in the thread Australian A-League - Macarthur v Sydney with Like Like.
    Just not great officiating all round. No need for VAR to get involved whatsoever there, and really poor from the referee to change their...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS replied to the thread Everton - Forest.
    How many games has your fictional manager refereed in front of hundreds? This is a theoretical suggested improvement. Current IFAB...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS replied to the thread Australian A-League - Macarthur v Sydney.
    The overarching trend in England is of too much caution when it comes to the VAR getting involved. So my guess is that it's much more...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS replied to the thread Everton - Forest.
    Charitable reading - Clatts phoned Webb to ask him if this was a conflict of interests, he/Forest considered that putting in a request...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS reacted to OnlyUseMeWhistle's post in the thread Everton - Forest with Like Like.
    I'd buy this if a Forest loss benefitted Luton clearly, but a draw is arguably a better result because Luton play Everton in the coming...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS reacted to The Gump's post in the thread Everton - Forest with Like Like.
    Spot on. Clattenburg knew exactly what he was doing in making that request/comment to PGMOL beforehand - any controversial decision was...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS reacted to DJIC's post in the thread Everton - Forest with Like Like.
    I agree about retired officals not always best suited for VAR. I would add the noise in the VAR room must make it incredibly difficult...
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS replied to the thread Everton - Forest.
    And I think that's an argument that needs to be examined and considered - not just accepted as irrefutable truth as it seems to be now.
  • GraemeS
    GraemeS replied to the thread City vs Chelsea.
    Fair enough, correction noted - but I don't think it materially changes the point I was making.
Show older items
Back
Top