The Ref Stop

Injury Question

Donate to RefChat

Help keep RefChat running, any donation would be appreciated

Referee220378

New Member
Level 7 Referee
Had a scenario yesterday where a player kicks the ball out of play for his team mate to receive treatment, I subsequently instruct the physio to enter the field of play, but as I do so the injured party jumps to his feet and decides he doesn’t want or need treatment, I therefore stop the physio from entering the field of play but insist the player leaves the pitch for one minute.

Was I right in law?
 
The Ref Stop
Had a scenario yesterday where a player kicks the ball out of play for his team mate to receive treatment, I subsequently instruct the physio to enter the field of play, but as I do so the injured party jumps to his feet and decides he doesn’t want or need treatment, I therefore stop the physio from entering the field of play but insist the player leaves the pitch for one minute.

Was I right in law?
Correct in Law as you had authorised the physio to enter the field of play. If the potentially injured player is nearby and you have the opportunity to quickly check without delaying the restart, then that can help to avoid unnecessarily calling on the physio and then the player can stay on.

The Law puts responsibility on players over treatment. A player who is only slightly injured can avoid the one minute delay if they either:
  • Inform the referee they don't want treatment before the referee has to stop play, delay a restart or call on the physio
  • Inform the referee they need to leave the field for treatment and then do so without having play stopped or delayed
 
Thanks for the reply.

My argument to justify my decision was the deliberate kicking of the ball out play in my opinion is deemed as an act of ‘stopping play’

Can you confirm if that scenario had incurred, I had checked with the player, and he didn’t require attention, that he therefore wouldn’t have had to leave the field of play?
 
Thanks for the reply.

My argument to justify my decision was the deliberate kicking of the ball out play in my opinion is deemed as an act of ‘stopping play’

Can you confirm if that scenario had incurred, I had checked with the player, and he didn’t require attention, that he therefore wouldn’t have had to leave the field of play?
Correct, if the opposition were able to take their restart without delay then the player would stay on the field.
Play was stopped as a result of the ball going out of play, therefore technically was not stopped as a result of the injury.
 
Correct in Law as you had authorised the physio to enter the field of play. If the potentially injured player is nearby and you have the opportunity to quickly check without delaying the restart, then that can help to avoid unnecessarily calling on the physio and then the player can stay on.

The Law puts responsibility on players over treatment. A player who is only slightly injured can avoid the one minute delay if they either:
  • Inform the referee they don't want treatment before the referee has to stop play, delay a restart or call on the physio
  • Inform the referee they need to leave the field for treatment and then do so without having play stopped or delayed
I can't find what you have quoted but I have this which somewhat contradicts your assertion.

1000050640.jpg
 
Which assertion does that contradict?
That it is the responsibility of player to tell referees that they don't want a physio (instead of the referee asking the injured player which my snippet suggests) .

The delaying the restart bit is in Law 5.
Where in law 5 are the two dot points you referred. Or more in general "The Law puts responsibility on players over treatment.". Not a rhetorical question, I genuinely can't find it. My snippet is from the "Off-field treatment and assessment protocol" at the start of the book.
 
IMO, I’d be a bit more lenient here, if the physio has made a quick retreat from the field, then not apply the 1 minute, a misunderstanding, player kicks ball off field and the referee waves physios on.
 
I think kicking the ball out of play is absolutely not Law means here. It means the ref stops play because of the injury (rather than play stops because the ball leaves the field). I think, however, that you were technically right to apply the o e minute because you signalled the physio to come on (second bullet). Per the Law, it is the signal, not the physio coming on that triggers the minute.

I think a take away from the scenario is to pause before signaling the physio on and make sure it is necessary if the ball is out of play.

Addition: I also wouldn’t fault a ref who did not make the player leave in the OP. IMO SOTG could reasonably support “my bad, thought you needed it, let’s play” and get on with it despite the technical requirement here.
 
That it is the responsibility of player to tell referees that they don't want a physio (instead of the referee asking the injured player which my snippet suggests) .


Where in law 5 are the two dot points you referred. Or more in general "The Law puts responsibility on players over treatment.". Not a rhetorical question, I genuinely can't find it. My snippet is from the "Off-field treatment and assessment protocol" at the start of the book.
My bullet points are not written in Law but are a consequence of it. Players with slight injuries have a choice either they take the initiative or they don't and when they don't they are more likely to be required to serve the minute off.
 
The concern and question I have here, is that, can’t teams therefore use this a means of time wasting, contravening the reason why the rule was bought in?

Scenario:

A team is 1-0 up with minimal time in the game remaining, defender goes down with cramp, shouts from his own players to kick the ball out so he can have treatment, referee makes his way over to the player, only for him to say he’s fine and slowly gets to his feet, making the most of the break in play, attacking team the feel obliged to return the subsequent throw in back to the defending team.

Isn’t that a deliberate attempt to waste time and exactly why the player in question should leave the field for one minute to prevent that whole scenario?
 
Last edited:
Just stop the watch for time lost. Opponents are under no obligation.

Same as you would if the player received treatment and had to leave the pitch for a minute

Seems the example I’ve given is therefore a legitimate way to slow down the game without any consequences for the player in question in that case? Yet a genuinely injured player has to take a consequence of receiving treatment. Madness.
 
They concede a restart.

Players cannot be treated on the FOP.

Players made this an issue, not us.
I think your missing my point and having spoken to a level 3 referee / observer this afternoon they seem to be in agreement that the scenario I explain should result in the said player being asked to leave the field of play for one minute, the justification being that the ‘deliberate act’ of kicking the ball out of play for the player to receive treatment, meets the threshold to implement law.

His opinion was that in that scenario he would have ushered the physio onto the field of play as soon as the ball was kicked out of play, as the fact the ball was kicked out of play by one of his own team mates was enough justification to assume he needed treatment.
 
Last edited:
The language of the Law does not support automatically applying the minute if the team kicks the ball out. I agree with the observer: if the R thinks the team is playing games, then call on the physio. Then the minute applies, whether the player wants it or not. But if the R doesn’t do that, the Law, as currently written, doesn’t support applying the minute.
 
Subject to any exceptions by virtue of how the player was injured (not stated in the OP), the ball is kicked out of play, so if the R does not instruct 'Play On' immediately and have the throw in taken, then the restart is delayed and the player must leave the FOP.. (Law 5).
 
@Kevin0954 If this was the case then why would the law mention the referee asking a player if he needs treatment and having to go off if doesn't request it.
In that instance the referee has delayed the restart to ask the question.
 
Subject to any exceptions by virtue of how the player was injured (not stated in the OP), the ball is kicked out of play, so if the R does not instruct 'Play On' immediately and have the throw in taken, then the restart is delayed and the player must leave the FOP.. (Law 5).

Law 5 doesn’t say that.
 
Back
Top