You Are The Ref! - Again!

[GraemeS]

are people playing develis advocate here with the specific wording in the laws or do you genuinely believe it should be a yellow??

When it was clearly going to hit his chest anyway? If I'm 100% confident that's true then yes, I'd happily go with PK and yellow.

If there's the slightest chance I think he's used that shirt stretch to make himself wider then he'd be off.

 

[es1]

When it was clearly going to hit his chest anyway? If I'm 100% confident that's true then yes, I'd happily go with PK and yellow.

If there's the slightest chance I think he's used that shirt stretch to make himself wider then he'd be off.

fair enough

 

[PinnerPaul]

For clarity, the illustration accompanying the question, clearly shows that the ball would have hit defender's chest if he hadn't pulled his shirt out in front of him.

Typical example of a Hackett question that has as much chance of happening in real life as I have of watching the Rs in the Champions League!