Only Yellow!

[JH]

https://streamable.com/5lasy
Say no more...

 

[ARF]

Wowzer

 

[Sheffields Finest]

Lucky lucky that wasn't a very serious injury! Retrospective uplift possibly??

 

[Ciley Myrus]

Lucky lucky that wasn't a very serious injury! Retrospective uplift possibly??

Am at work and cant see it but am guessing its bad seeing as even you are not simply playing on like 1983 !!


edit have seen it now..very much a red !

 

[Sheffields Finest]

Am at work and cant see it but am guessing its bad seeing as even you are not simply playing on like 1983 !!

You would have walked for this one too in 1983...... Maybe not 1963!!!

 

[Sheffields Finest]

 

[Viking]

How about, he pulled out of the challenge, didn't go with his studs, just a bit reckless.

 

[Ciley Myrus]

How about, he pulled out of the challenge, didn't go with his studs, just a bit reckless.

Based on the pic, even if he "pulls out" its still a red !!
A bit reckless? Not intending to be offensive or personal but if you are judging that as a bit reckless then you need a refresher in SFP before your next appointment sorry !!

 

[Sheffields Finest]

If I say its red then there is a pretty good chance that my high threshold for SFP has been breached.....Its higher than most I would guess!!

 

[Viking]

I do enjoy your comments CM. I was playing devils advocate a bit because that was the suggestion made by a FL AR for a similar incident at a recent RA meeting. The assessor noted red though which I was pleased to hear.

 

[Big Cat]

How about, he pulled out of the challenge, didn't go with his studs, just a bit reckless.

Slomose and freeze frames are fairly worthless

 

[Sheffields Finest]

TBF, Its about as out of control as you can get, thankfully it looks like he retracted his leading boots and just hit him with his trailing shins, It wasn't pretty!!! RC, no bother!!

 

[QuaverRef]

How about, he pulled out of the challenge, didn't go with his studs, just a bit reckless.

Whether he leads with his studs or not, it has to be a red. Your match control is out the window if you try and justify that as a yellow

 

[one]

How about, he pulled out of the challenge, didn't go with his studs, just a bit reckless.

There are a couple of elements in there that make you think yellow. But a lot more elements to point to red. You assess this on the whole and on the on the whole it fits the definition of excessive force which means red.

 

[Tino Best]

easy red

 

[Mintyref]

There are a couple of elements in there that make you think yellow. But a lot more elements to point to red. You assess this on the whole and on the on the whole it fits the definition of excessive force which means red.

Where.........? Red without any doubt...

 

[one]

Where.........? Red without any doubt...

Both knees bent. Studs are pointing down. I think it's a red. And if had any doubt I would have said it too but I didn't. I thing you are reading too much into my post.

 

[Sheffields Finest]

Both knees bent. Studs are pointing down. I think it's a red. And if had any doubt I would have said it too but I didn't. I thing you are reading too much into my post.

Cut the over thinking @one..... @Mintyref has already decreed the answer on this one!!!

 

[one]

My post was in response to Viking's "How about...". Are we really going to turn this into an argument even though we agree? Seriously. Let me watch my Sunday night movie in peace .

 

[GraemeS]

I see what one is getting at: although the launching off the ground was mad, there's room for this to have been a lot worse if he didn't realise he's missed the ball and attempted to pull out. It's obvious red, but I think there is a slight overraction in some of the above responses, I've seen far worse tackles than this.