socal lurker
RefChat Addict
Well, I've never said that IFAB could draft worth a damn . . . they are notorious for trying to tie up one little issue and creating 6 new ones.
Fortunately this is an extremely rare circumstance, and for those of us without VAR, we're simply going to make the best judgment we can and rely on Law 18 (common sense) to guide us in making a decision that is fair in the moment.
As far as the defender language, here's what I believe it actually means. (Note that it doesn't say anything about re-entering in there; the re-entering language only applies to attackers.) I believe the defender language isn't about re-entering, but about when we stop considering the defender off the field to be on the goal line. E.g., when a defender takes himself off the field because he is injured or in a fit about a perceived bad call by the ref. Even though he is still off the field, we are to stop "counting" him as a defender "until the next stoppage in play or until the defending team has played the ball towards the halfway line and it is outside its penalty area"--in other words, until the immediate attack is ended so that the attacking team is not unfairly disadvantaged. (And the idea that it is played all the way back by the attacking team and doesn't reset is kinda funny to think about, but in real life, once the ball is far away from the attack, I think IFAB expects us to stop "counting" that off the field defender.)
Fortunately this is an extremely rare circumstance, and for those of us without VAR, we're simply going to make the best judgment we can and rely on Law 18 (common sense) to guide us in making a decision that is fair in the moment.
As far as the defender language, here's what I believe it actually means. (Note that it doesn't say anything about re-entering in there; the re-entering language only applies to attackers.) I believe the defender language isn't about re-entering, but about when we stop considering the defender off the field to be on the goal line. E.g., when a defender takes himself off the field because he is injured or in a fit about a perceived bad call by the ref. Even though he is still off the field, we are to stop "counting" him as a defender "until the next stoppage in play or until the defending team has played the ball towards the halfway line and it is outside its penalty area"--in other words, until the immediate attack is ended so that the attacking team is not unfairly disadvantaged. (And the idea that it is played all the way back by the attacking team and doesn't reset is kinda funny to think about, but in real life, once the ball is far away from the attack, I think IFAB expects us to stop "counting" that off the field defender.)