The Ref Stop

How is that not spotted!!!

Donate to RefChat

Help keep RefChat running, any donation would be appreciated

Swings and roundabouts. He could have sent Lovren off for S7 for getting involved after the Barkley challenge, but equally could have sent Barkley off for delaying the restart. Both would have been soft in my opinion and he did the right thing in the context of the game. Like it or not, and I know there are those that don't agree, at that level you are managing an event, not just a game of football, and also have a responsibility to the paying public. If top level referees applied the letter of the law to the strictest level they simply wouldn't be top level referees for very long.

Of course this doesn't apply to the Barkley challenge, that should clearly be a red card regardless of what game it is in. I can see why Mike Dean has missed it, as real time it just looked like a standard yellow card, but when they then showed the angle from behind the benches it looked like a shocker. I think Dean has followed the ball and not used the trailing eye, but you would have liked to have thought that one of his colleagues could have bailed him out.
 
The Ref Stop
I was lambasted on another thread for stating I would not issue mandatory cautions but would 'manage' the game......so you see I'm better than you all thought and I'm just agreeing to officiate the same way as my elite premiership referee peers..........
 
Technically no because this caused another incident between Barkley and Henderson that Dean had to diffuse. But the intent was there and it was successful in delaying the restart.

@Charlie Jones I dont disagree and I accept what you say, I disagree that should be the situation we find ourselves in every weekend.
Say the Premier League is your goal. At what point in your career does it become acceptable to not apply the law as to manage the event. Because level 4 onwardssome spectators are paying for entry, albeit small change. Supply league club round the corner charges a pound on the gate. So from then? Or l3 at contrib. Or only when the tele people come along? I wonder if mike dean would lose a mark or gain a mark by his handling of that situation because i know what would happen to me? Id lose a mark. And again, thats not really fair is it? Im sure you agree with all of this and mayhe you have a better perspective of us and them but i personally think, particularly when the punishment is equal, the laws should be applied the same at all levels.

I don't disagree with anything that you've said - I honestly don't ... I think, not so much a 'better' perspective, but ive just kinda learned to not compare to what they do incorrect to me, but rather I learn from what they do well - i.e positioning etc.
 
I've just flicked through the Discipline section of the LOTG to no avail! Can someone point me to the right Section labelled, 'Managing an Event'

Apparently there is some secret section where us mere mortals can't go. It basically involves doing Jack Shidt if it upsets the paylords!
 
Last edited:
I was lambasted on another thread for stating I would not issue mandatory cautions but would 'manage' the game......so you see I'm better than you all thought and I'm just agreeing to officiate the same way as my elite premiership referee peers..........
Can I have my books back now you've cracked it Minty?? I'm in HU17 after xmas, maybe another brew is on offer??
 

Attachments

  • s-l1000.jpg
    s-l1000.jpg
    111.7 KB · Views: 8
Sounds good, when you coming across, my round I think.....
6th January, early doors i'm at Acklam Coaches, Barmaston Close, Bev and may get another call in Grimsby (not sure).

Will Matron let you out of the OAP home without a pass these days? :angel:
 
Back
Top