Doh

[CapnBloodbeard]

given that there was a dangerous situation that was in no way going to resolve itself without a foul due to players on the ground, but nobody at fault, nothing wrong with putting down a DB. Unusual, but an option.

 

[santa sangria]

given that there was a dangerous situation that was in no way going to resolve itself without a foul due to players on the ground, but nobody at fault, nothing wrong with putting down a DB. Unusual, but an option.

Good idea... unless 12 players decide to contest on the edge of the 6 yard box.. I know I would!

 

[Padfoot]

Not sure why the snowflakes are getting their panties in a wad over what was posted......you make decisions up every game.....

Not sure if it was a corner or GK?.....you go with the safest option....that’s a made up decision.
Not sure which way the throw was?.....you go with the safest option.....that’s a made up decision.

As I said, dismount from your lofty equestrian perch and give your craniums an oscillation!

 

[Ciley Myrus]

Not sure why the snowflakes are getting their panties in a wad over what was posted......you make decisions up every game.....

Not sure if it was a corner or GK?.....you go with the safest option....that’s a made up decision.
Not sure which way the throw was?.....you go with the safest option.....that’s a made up decision.

As I said, dismount from your lofty equestrian perch and give your craniums an oscillation!

Nowhere near the same. Ball goes out for a throw, you have to award it to one of the teams, correctly or incorrectly. Ball out of play is real, factual
Inventing a push in the ball is mythical. You are giving a fk for a non existent offence
This has already been highlighted but you still try to justify creating a fk for something which did not happen

 

[JamesL]

Not sure why the snowflakes are getting their panties in a wad over what was posted......you make decisions up every game.....

Not sure if it was a corner or GK?.....you go with the safest option....that’s a made up decision.
Not sure which way the throw was?.....you go with the safest option.....that’s a made up decision.

As I said, dismount from your lofty equestrian perch and give your craniums an oscillation!

Apples and oranges padders.
Throw ins/corners we are doing it because we dont know what has happened but we have to make a decision. So we take a safe option.

There's no guessing about the OP scenario. We know exactly what happened and you suggest we manipulate the outcome, for what reason?

There's no spirit of the game issue here. There is clear guidance in law about what should happen in this situation.

 

[Padfoot]

Nowhere near the same. Ball goes out for a throw, you have to award it to one of the teams, correctly or incorrectly. Ball out of play is real, factual
Inventing a push in the ball is mythical. You are giving a fk for a non existent offence
This has already been highlighted but you still try to justify creating a fk for something which did not happen

Once again, for terminally hard of understanding, nowhere have I said ‘invent a foul’.

People really need to stop making things up.

 

[JamesL]

Once again, for terminally hard of understanding, nowhere have I said ‘invent a foul’.

People really need to stop making things up.

But it was implied by the words find and use of '. And you know it.

 

[ASM]

Bored of this now