Help keep RefChat running, any donation would be appreciated
A bit concerning that there are referees out there recommending a Sin Bin for a non-dissent offence.![]()
Well I think you're wrong.I think it can be considered dissent—the comment is being made in response to a call. So if you aren’t going red (which is where I would get) I think dissent is the next best option.
The way I read the OP, it is in response to a foul not givenWell I think you're wrong.
Based on the OP's description, it wasn't "in response to a call" and even if it was, it isn't "public disagreement with a match officials decision" - it was an insult pure and simple.
Of course it's not "OFFINABUS". Possibly dissent but I'd judge that on the day based on what had gone since KO. Manner of delivery is always key except when the words used make that aspect null and void.You don't give a player a foul he believes you should have given and in response he says to you 'you're miles off it' (something I've heard a lot).
Is this OFFINABUS or a caution for dissent? (Or neither)
You're correct, it isn't OFFINABUS, but ITOOTR (me), being told I'm 'miles off it' is exactly the same as telling me I'm sh*t. I'm used to colloquial/industrial language and they mean exactly the same thing. So if it's public enough to be a challenge to my match control it can be sanctioned as dissent, but it's not OFFINABUS to me (unless it was delivered in an extremely aggressive manor, but then I'd be sanctioning for the delivery of it, not the words.) I don't see how you can argue that it can not be treated as dissent if the referee doesn't see it as abusive/offensive but sees it as a public disagreeement.Of course it's not "OFFINABUS". Possibly dissent but I'd judge that on the day based on what had gone since KO. Manner of delivery is always key except when the words used make that aspect null and void.
An insult is an insult for me. Upon hearing it, I'll do one of two things: Pull him in, read him the riot act and then get on with the game or produce the red card. I'm certainly not giving a dissent Sin Bin or caution for somebody telling me I'm 5hit!
There's a 'swear filter' on this site (and also many other forum sites). If you type a word that is on its list of offensive terms, it will replace the word with asterisks when you post.Thank you so much for your feedback. The word in asterisks is s-h-i-t, not sure why the asterisks. I had written down the actual word.
Really?You're correct, it isn't OFFINABUS, but ITOOTR (me), being told I'm 'miles off it' is exactly the same as telling me I'm sh*t.
Horses for courses.So if it's public enough to be a challenge to my match control it can be sanctioned as dissent, but it's not OFFINABUS to me (unless it was delivered in an extremely aggressive manor, but then I'd be sanctioning for the delivery of it, not the words.) I don't see how you can argue that it can not be treated as dissent if the referee doesn't see it as abusive/offensive but sees it as a public disagreeement.

And herein lies the answer Sir. To you, it's an insult, and that's fine, and nobody said you would be incorrect to dismiss for it. To me, it's not, and therefore I'm not incorrect in sin binning for it (if I were doing a game where sin bins are applicable) because I deem it to be dissent.Maybe they do (to you) but whining, moaning, complaining, arguing, refuting etc. can all be deemed as dissent (depending upon the individual referee) whereas an insult is an insult for me - not dissent.![]()
As to the first part, I don't know how you get to it not being in response to a call. The OP states: "a defender close to me was complaining about what he claimed as a foul that I had not given just instances before. As I was close to him, 2m or so, I turn around to talk to him, and he shouted at me directly at my face, "You are ****!" The insult was about the call that was not made. That can certainly be considered dissent by a referee who is somehow not insulted by having someone shout "You are ****!" directly in their face. The more I ponder this the less I can understand those who would not send off for that. But if they don't, there is clearly dissent there, too. Not at least cautioning here seems a recipe for disaster. But ultimately we agree on the most important part of this--the player should go for this behavior. And I'd humbly suggest that those who do not send off for this, make it harder on the next referee. Just because we can deal with inappropriate behavior doesn't mean we should. We should all be trying to establish that certain behavior is simply unacceptable on the pitch.Well I think you're wrong.
Based on the OP's description, it wasn't "in response to a call" and even if it was, it isn't "public disagreement with a match officials decision" - it was an insult pure and simple.
I think it's about how it's said. I agree that screamed right in ones face is a red card offence. Someone telling me I'm sh*t under their breath or out of frustration without shouting it loudly would get a different action. I don't think anyone who sends off for everything that could be deemed to be an insult would ever make it very far in the game.As to the first part, I don't know how you get to it not being in response to a call. The OP states: "a defender close to me was complaining about what he claimed as a foul that I had not given just instances before. As I was close to him, 2m or so, I turn around to talk to him, and he shouted at me directly at my face, "You are ****!" The insult was about the call that was not made. That can certainly be considered dissent by a referee who is somehow not insulted by having someone shout "You are ****!" directly in their face. The more I ponder this the less I can understand those who would not send off for that. But if they don't, there is clearly dissent there, too. Not at least cautioning here seems a recipe for disaster. But ultimately we agree on the most important part of this--the player should go for this behavior. And I'd humbly suggest that those who do not send off for this, make it harder on the next referee. Just because we can deal with inappropriate behavior doesn't mean we should. We should all be trying to establish that certain behavior is simply unacceptable on the pitch.
Said the L2 match official to the L5.I don't think anyone who sends off for everything that could be deemed to be an insult would ever make it very far in the game.

Said the L2 match official to the L5.![]()
![]()
Be abandoned before the pre-match cuppa!I'd find it hard to believe you've sent off for everything you've ever heard that could be insulting!