A&H

Deliberate play for offside

What you've both written makes sense to most (including me) but my point was, that's not what the extract above from the
book says.
 
A&H International
Kes said:
What you've both written makes sense to most (including me) but my point was, that's not what the extract above from the
book says.
Click to expand...
I'm struggling with that. It clearly says deliberate play and the definition of play is:
"Action by a player which makes contact with the ball"
 
JamesL said:
I'm struggling with that. It clearly says deliberate play and the definition of play is:
"Action by a player which makes contact with the ball"
Click to expand...
Agreed. But for the purposes of this thread and the extract quoted in connection with it, this:

Deliberate play’ is when a player has control of the ball with the possibility of:

  • passing the ball to a team-mate; or
  • gaining possession of the ball; or
  • clearing the ball (e.g. by kicking or heading it).

.... doesn't say that.

That's all I'm saying. Don't shoot the messenger!! ;) :p
 
The passage above the previous passage I quoted says:
A player in an offside position receiving the ball from an opponent who deliberately plays the ball, including by deliberate handball, is not considered to have gained an advantage, unless it was a deliberate save by any opponent.
Click to expand...

If the defender doesn't make contact then the player in the offside position isn't receiving the ball from that player, thus rendering the rest irrelevant, it would revert to whether he was offside from the original pass.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Kes
@Kes I think you are reading that section in isolation and overthinking the whole new section.

Deliberate play is still a play right? If the defender doesn't touch the ball, in the context of the OP we shouldn't be reading past the second word in the section you quoted as it won't apply if there is no 'play' by the defender.
 
RefereeX said:
The passage above the previous passage I quoted says:


If the defender doesn't make contact then the player in the offside position isn't receiving the ball from that player, thus rendering the rest irrelevant, it would revert to whether he was offside from the original pass.
Click to expand...
Yeah, well I didn't read that cos you never quoted it and anyway I just wanted to be a pedant cos I ain't been one on here for ages but I'm over it now. :p :angel:
 
one said:
@Kes I think you are reading that section in isolation and overthinking the whole new section.

Deliberate play is still a play right? If the defender doesn't touch the ball, in the context of the OP we shouldn't be reading past the second word in the section you quoted as it won't apply if there is no 'play' by the defender.
Click to expand...
Agreed. (See above).
Unlike yourself and some others, I don't have an encyclopaedic knowledge of the Laws (that's not intended as offensive or sarcastic btw) and generally need to scour the IFAB app I have in order to find the correct answer for some of the less common events that occur during a match. Especially if observing!!

I'll step away from this thread now and confine myself to picking you (and JamesL) up for your spelling and grammar only in future ... ;):D
 
  • Like
Reactions: one
Kes said:
Agreed. (See above).
Unlike yourself and some others, I don't have an encyclopaedic knowledge of the Laws (that's not intended as offensive or sarcastic btw) and generally need to scour the IFAB app I have in order to find the correct answer for some of the less common events that occur during a match. Especially if observing!!

I'll step away from this thread now and confine myself to picking you (and JamesL) up for your spelling and grammar only in future ... ;):D
Click to expand...
Plese continu to poast on topicks two so I can pick yew up in return for beying rong in lore.
 
Kes said:
Yeah, well I didn't read that cos you never quoted it and anyway I just wanted to be a pedant cos I ain't been one on here for ages but I'm over it now. :p :angel:
Click to expand...
My late Grandma used to say ''ain't' ain't grammar and it never are been'.

Edit: She was wrong, of course, but she still said it...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top