Citee Pool then

[RobOda]

Any thoughts on a possible penalty/DOGSO if Salah doesn't chip it in?

Think so. Might be harsh, but from the angle I've seen it looks like he's just tried to push him, so penalty, red.

Looks like it was a great advantage to give, assuming the ref did so.

 

[santa sangria]

Think so. Might be harsh, but from the angle I've seen it looks like he's just tried to push him, so penalty, red.

Looks like it was a great advantage to give, assuming the ref did so.

Red even given the proximity of the other defender (between Mane and the goal) and lack of control over the ball...?

 

[GraemeS]

Red even given the proximity of the other defender (between Mane and the goal) and lack of control over the ball...?

https://twitter.com/x/status/983799324835532801

All the defenders are behind him when the middle of the 3 bumps into the back on him and makes him stagger - the player in the RCB position only "gets position" because Mane's slower when he's trying to recover his feet and that's when the RCB overtakes him. I could go either way, but I think there's definitely a case for red.

 

[santa sangria]

All the defenders are behind him when the middle of the 3 bumps into the back on him and makes him stagger - the player in the RCB position only "gets position" because Mane's slower when he's trying to recover his feet and that's when the RCB overtakes him. I could go either way, but I think there's definitely a case for red.

Can't see the vid. Fair enough.

 

[akokkalis]

2nd goal of City it was a goal or offside? And why?

 

[santa sangria]

DO THE ROBOT BOBBY MY SON!!!!!!!

 

[santa sangria]

Otamendi makes his significant contribution

 

[RobOda]

2nd goal of City it was a goal or offside? And why?

It was disallowed for offside, but was onside... From what I've seen anyway.

 

[santa sangria]

2nd goal of City it was a goal or offside? And why?

Goal.
Milner played the ball. It was not a deflection (or a save).

 

[santa sangria]

AR2 is 'avin' a blinder though

 

[Mooseybaby]

Should have placed a bet on how many times Sane would be caught offside!

 

[Tealeaf]

No complaints over that second disallowed goal.

Wonder what the odds of City shipping 3 goals for the third game in a row were after 2 minutes of the match? Still time for it

 

[GraemeS]

Should have placed a bet on how many times Sane would be caught offside!

I don't think they'd take a bet for a high enough number!

 

[Yampy]

Forza Roma!

 

[akokkalis]

Goal.
Milner played the ball. It was not a deflection (or a save).

It seems to.me like a deflection

 

[santa sangria]

Meanwhile in Rome...

 

[santa sangria]

It seems to.me like a deflection

I really don't think so. He sticks his knee out to stop it reaching the attacker. Milner actively, deliberately plays the ball. He knows about the ball. It's not a deflection according to the LotG AFAIK.

 

[RobOda]

Fantastic from Roma.

 

[santa sangria]

Open goal!

 

[RobOda]

I really don't think so. He sticks his knee out to stop it reaching the attacker. Milner actively, deliberately plays the ball. He knows about the ball. It's not a deflection according to the LotG AFAIK.

Okay, I'm tired so...

Isn't this irrelevant.

Sane was onside when the ball was last touched by De Bruyne?