Can C3 be used for "dissent with aggressive intent"?

[pompeydunc]

I’ve never done this, but I really wish SinBins acted as normal cautions, and picking 2 up leaves your team down to 10 men, and a red card for S7.

I find the way SinBins are in play at the moment genuinely infuriating. They do work, the first SinBin is often enough to cool down most people and take the dissent out the game.

But I had to caution a player for C4, then he gave me dissent, so I had to SinBin him for C2. Imagine trying to explain showing 2 yellow cards; but no red at Sunday League.

The way I see it, he’s commited 2 cautionable offences, but stayed on the pitch for the whole of the second half, that’s a cop out it anything.

Feel free to disagree, but I really wish they’d act like normal cautions in terms of picking up 2 per game.

Totally agree. It should be an extra punishment - caution and ten minutes in sin bin. Any further cautions, and you're off. It would make it so much simpler to understand.

 

[george.g]

I find the fact it doesn’t carry a fine either, also irritating. Players are being fined for handball for example, but not for dissent.

I find the system overly complex, as you’ve said. and it doesn’t effectively punish dissent in my
opinion.

Totally agree. It should be an extra punishment - caution and ten minutes in sin bin. Any further cautions, and you're off. It would make it so much simpler to understand.