A&H

Search results

  1. P

    Bristol City v West Ham

    Bristol post. Bristol City vs West Ham, VAR, and the clear divide that is widening in football The crunching tackles and "handbags" at Ashton Gate show how VAR is creating two versions of the same game Bristol City beat West Ham United in a FA Cup tie and a significant part of the post-match...
  2. P

    Bristol City v West Ham

    Joe Williams on Ings. Potential modern day sending off with VAR.
  3. P

    Pal v Eve

    Overturned. I am 2 out of 2 on these now. It was no foul.
  4. P

    match off but pitch fine

    A ref is an official. Leagues are fine with officials sharing concerns over fixtures not being played. Clubs entering leagues have made a commitment to x of games in x period of time, and leagues do not like games to be called off for spurious reasons like FA Cup games being played on a Sunday...
  5. P

    Pal v Eve

    Then its highlighting the subjective. Was there excessive force? No. Reckless? Seems in control and the player is not going to top him. Am I chucking around reds for that sunday at a U16 game? No way. does the ref make a clear and obvious error? no. its only a red in one part of football. That...
  6. P

    Pal v Eve

    I cant see a foul, or anything reckless, and certainly no clear and obvious error by a ref performing well.
  7. P

    85% correct

    Yes. It was not specific. Clever analogy.
  8. P

    85% correct

    Who actually are they? What are their experiences of refereeing? Are they all qualified in refereeing football at all?
  9. P

    98% of ref decisions are correct

    Yes, and in a hyper analytical football world there should be up to date data on refs and their % of correct decisions, and incorrect. Anybody?
  10. P

    98% of ref decisions are correct

    https://blog.innerdrive.co.uk/sports/var-and-referee-biases Does anybody have a link to up to date data?
  11. P

    DOGSO? BCFC V SWFC

    I was thinking can I create a scenario where DOGSO can apply on the half way line and my understanding was yes. Thank you.
  12. P

    DOGSO? BCFC V SWFC

    Of course. 110% it was not a red card. There are those who know football, and those who don't. Forgetting the jest. Sincere question. The D of distance - How far from goal should dogso not apply?
  13. P

    DOGSO? BCFC V SWFC

    No I think its good to use football knowledge to understand whats going on as a ref. You were adamant the defender only went backwards and was not in front of the keeper and it was 1-1 . Applying football knowledge well thats incorrect another picture. It was not 1v1 v the keeper and that...
  14. P

    DOGSO? BCFC V SWFC

    I will leave it to those who know a lot more than me ad most will but law 12 includes dogso and them considerations with a C. All good anyway. Good night.
  15. P

    DOGSO? BCFC V SWFC

    . As others have said including the former top ref Keith you can see this differently. Why they are doing what they are doing really should be a consideration and again there are refs on this thread who are considering that to hold merit. And that was it. A difference of opinion on laws that...
  16. P

    DOGSO? BCFC V SWFC

    Nothing invented. I would apply them laws to this. As others have said no obvious dogso including top ex refs on that x . Too much going on. Disagree agree and this one Its just a matter of differing perception this one.
  17. P

    DOGSO? BCFC V SWFC

    The considerations in the rules are not made up. Which is why in my first post I have asked dogso? The defender would have gone to the attacking player space if the gk didn't. The keepers up sharp to narrow the angle and push the attacking player away from goal. The touch does take the player...
  18. P

    DOGSO? BCFC V SWFC

    I am merely asking some whys. Thats it in regards to the Sheff W players I am not making up my interpretations regarding what they are doing at this point. They started out of shape and move into pretty text book defending principles to get to this point where Bannan? then upends the attacker...
  19. P

    DOGSO? BCFC V SWFC

    As a very qualified coach ex semi pro defender and now well meaning trying to always do better ref the process is D deny space, D delay D dictate D depth and the defender are hitting d's because they 100% are not off to the goal line!! The keeper is denying space and attempting to dictate where...
  20. P

    DOGSO? BCFC V SWFC

    Thank you. My understanding was there. I am not in detention. At one point the defender is between the attacker and gk marginally but the big point was its not 1v1 and the keeper comes across the defender towards the attacker and his team mate adjusts position to cover the goal and they both...
Back
Top