Search results

I disagree here. It’s clearly u sporting behaviour. Like shouting when someone is about to kick the ball. Either way, it’s certainly not in the spirit of the game. As for the keeper, yes he should be more aware, but in the same light, he doesn’t expect a player to come in from outside the...

I think you could argue that when he hesitates to get back in he is now officially off the field of play and hence I would argue you fan caution for entering field play without permission. Regardless equally can caution for unsporting behaviour l, unspecified.

I have to say I would have disallowed this goal. He lurks off the pitch waiting for it. At this point, I would consider him off the pitch and he now needs my permission to come onto the pitch. At worst I would have him as general unsporting behaviour and issue a card. I could be wrong though...

Yeah, I think the video should be disallowed, but it’s a tough call to make at lower levels. I hate all guidance that is left to subjectivity. Handball has always been a problem. The problem is when they simplified it they all handball was an offence, the game didn’t like it. So we are back to...

I saw this video online and it raised a question which I’m sure has been discussed before. Should this goal have stood? Is there any guidance on what handball immediately before scoring is? https://www.facebook.com/share/r/14kJUghzmD3/?mibextid=wwXIfr

Early on there was a retaliatory tackle by Argentina on England which by itself was a yellow card offence, but he also struck the back of the players head with force which is a clear red card offence for violent conduct. If ref missed it, why does VAR not get involved? Or am I wrong?

I was thinking the same. It makes the consequences of a red card meaningless. This all started because of Ronaldo getting a suspended red card sentence. As I said. Corruption. Be it because of finance or friendship it’s still corruption.

You’re right! That’s the key to it all.

Just to contradict myself a little. I thought ref today at England match was superb. Thought he handled a tough match really well. Tough game to manage and he handled it really well. Carded at the right time to control the match. Not sure why VAR getting involved in penalty. Thought it has to...

Well having just watched another game where the officiating was below what I expect of semi pro leagues, I stand by my original comment. As for corruption. Making the World Cup bigger is definition of greed and corruption. FIFA has enough money, but is greedy. Surprising for a non profit? And...

I think corruption in fifa has long been well established. I always defend referees. Even the best have an off day like anyone anywhere. I stand by my point that we should only have the best referees in this tournament and I fail to see how refereeing in say the Qatar league can in anyway make...

Which begs the question….why have they made it bigger?

Haha. Even then I still wouldn’t claim I could do a better job than the worst ref at the comp.

It’s not a disrespect to him personally. The league he referees is nowhere near the level of a European league or even American league. It’s like me claiming I can ref a premier league match given that I referee an amateur league. I would love the chance, but no way am I remotely qualified...

Having watch so many games, I’m wondering if anyone else thinks the standard of referees is lower than normal. I mean it’s been low for many tournaments ever since blatter offered referee positions in World Cup for votes to keep him in power, but it seems lower than normal. The last France game...

There have been some good performances, but they have been the exception rather than the rule. More the point, what’s var for. This was clearly a foul. No idea why var didn’t get involved. Same with penalty in England match.

I’m sorry, but how does the ref allow that Germany goal. What’s the point of VAR? I’m also sorry, the the level of officiating at the group stages of this World Cup has been atrocious. (In my opinion).

I’ve only just seen the sending off. I have to say that he touched him slightly. He went down like a bag of spanners and I actually thing it’s a dive. I know I’ll will get criticised for this view, but it’s a booking for a dive for me.

Number of defenders was always a criteria for DOGSO. Where are the new laws/guidelines on DOGSO.

That still doesn’t show the direction the ball is travelling and having a person to pass to isn’t a criteria for DOGSO. Direction of travel was taking him wider.