The Ref Stop

Search results

  1. C

    Spurs v Arsenal WSL hand ball

    The arm first goes up rather independently of her overall body movement. Defenders should know by now that it's a big risk to have arms so far outstretched in the penalty area.
  2. C

    Sunderland v Brighton DOGSO

    Narrator: The KMI panel did not. https://www.premierleague.com/en/news/4744059/premier-league-match-round-6-key-match-incidents-panel-outcomes
  3. C

    How fast can i get promoted?

    You can be promoted in your first year, as long as you have joined the promotion pathway with your County FA.
  4. C

    Help with the step 4 fit

    What have you done to prepare so far?
  5. C

    Sunderland v Brighton DOGSO

    This did not meet the VAR threshold, but the sending off was a justifiable decision so overturning it is usurping the role of the referee.
  6. C

    Coventry v Newcastle

    Just a ragebait post isn't it? Rudoni's message wasn't advertising a song for his mate.
  7. C

    Open Age Abandoned

    Well done, the only one present who 'made it about themselves' was the captain. I wouldn't give the league official's lacklustre response a second thought, you've done your job correctly now it's up to them and the CFA. I have found it is usually a good idea to tell the departing player where...
  8. C

    Advantage or Quick Restart?

    Yes I agree. As soon as Green 80 deliberately handles the ball there can be no advantage, so the whistle needs to be blown to stop play for Yellow's handball offence.
  9. C

    Garforth Town vs Ossett United

    Looks to me like he's given simulation first too, especially as the whistle was supposedly blown. Then gets doubts and goes to ask AR1 what he thinks, and presumably gets told it wasn't simulation, so thinks the goal should be awarded due to advantage. Then gets reminded by AR1 that it can't be...
  10. C

    Man Utd vs Man City

    He also vocalises quite quickly that it should be a goal, and seems to have closed his mind to the possibility of other players offending in the APP.
  11. C

    Junior/Youth Young referee – intimidating behaviour from manager & linesman. What should I do?

    There is potentially a disciplinary issue too here both for the individual and the club.
  12. C

    Man Utd vs Man City

    It's worse than we thought, Donohue and Antrobus completely forgot to check whether Fernandez had committed an offside offence. They only checked for a touch by him in case it made Haaland offside. https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/articles/cv4g5rp56p55o There is also discussion of the...
  13. C

    Junior/Youth Young referee – intimidating behaviour from manager & linesman. What should I do?

    The behaviour described is not acceptable, especially towards a U18. I would suggest submitting an extraordinary misconduct report on the Referee Portal, and copy it into an email to your County FA's RDO and Safeguarding Officer. Also the league should have a safeguarding officer. In your...
  14. C

    Man Utd vs Man City

    Because they awarded the later (wrong) offside offence, Haaland's, they have implicitly made a no offside decision against Fernandez. This is part of the APP so automatically reviewable once it has been determined that Haaland was factually not offside. The VAR and ref should communicate about...
  15. C

    Sheffield United vs Wolves

    On the face of it Jones is caught out in a bad position but we don't have the context for that from the clip. I agree it is close proximity but don't think the arm position so high is justifiable and looks deliberate!
  16. C

    Man Utd vs Man City

    Am I right in thinking we have no indication yet as to whether the on-field officials gave an explanation regarding Fernandez's interference, either on their own initiative or being asked by the VAR? If they did then this feels like a subjective situation, that Webb very recently said should be...
  17. C

    Man Utd vs Man City

    Well that was quicker than I expected for the 'minimal VAR intervention' line to get torn up.
  18. C

    Man Utd vs Man City

    The on field team should have explained why they didn't penalise Enzo. I am guessing they didn't think he did enough to impact the opponents, and VAR though it wasn't clear cut enough to recommend an on field review.
  19. C

    SWPL Partick v Celtic

    Interesting, a rare case of clubs wanting harsher punishments than refs.
Back
Top