The Ref Stop

Search results

  1. D

    West Brom 2 game ban for handball

    ….but can always hope!
  2. D

    Field conditions - dry weather

    Along with 3G pitches, desalination in Spain & Portugal & some new projects along similar lines have started in Turkey. It needs to happen here, along with some new reservoirs.
  3. D

    West Brom 2 game ban for handball

    Although this could open a can of worms (though it is accepted that this is not new), I think it’s a good thing & hopefully will deter others. People may say that the Referee etc should be suspended for not seeing it, but really - I couldn’t tell for sure until I saw various replays from various...
  4. D

    Field conditions - dry weather

    Funding from the foundation is not likely to ever be enough, but is all that can be expected. It’s currently funding all the replacement of concrete/unsafe perimeter walls etc
  5. D

    Field conditions - dry weather

    … and x % for future proofing, whereby depending upon the amount of usage, the anticipated life of a 3G has imo been shortened from what the makers originally thought would be the case (knowingly or unknowingly!!!).
  6. D

    What does immediately after mean?

    I tend to agree with you, though I think there are plenty of Referees out there at many different levels whereby even if you took away the immediateness, they would penalise for handball - whether the arms are in a natural position or not. They would not likely consider the criteria under Law...
  7. D

    Fa cup

    I didn’t think we can assume that everything carried on as if it didn’t happen, though it looks like this was a very rare occurrence because I’ve never heard of such an incident happening before. Still should not have happened.
  8. D

    Fa cup

    I am sure that most Referees want a big hole to open up when this happens, or to just remain under the duvet for a few days, but it’s not rocket science and the fundamental competition rules need to be known/understood.
  9. D

    Wolves v Blackburn

    I don’t think the safe option would have been the right decision, especially with the score-line as it was - needed to be brave if he trusted his instinct/gut which he did, especially from the position he had whereby I don’t think he would have guessed. From the long view down the pitch they...
  10. D

    Wolves v Blackburn

    Handball & from his position, inside the penalty area (or at least on the boundary line) - therefore a penalty kick.
  11. D

    reffing expectations v reward v enjoyment

    The game can’t afford to lose any Referees, let alone vastly experienced ones. However, I’ve been to 4 games between Step 3-6 and the time downs etc have quickened the game up considerably and for a neutral watcher has made them more enjoyable, even though perhaps harder to officiate than the...
  12. D

    Fa cup

    At a game I was at the first 3 things the Referee said to his AR’s were no extra time/pens (therefore replay if a draw), no sin bins & 5 subs.
  13. D

    Fa cup

    I get it, but on the other hand, my view has always been and which I have to believe is that over the course of the season those who get promoted deserve it & those who get demoted are sometimes unfortunate but the stats don’t lie. In between that there are officials who can have a very good...
  14. D

    Fa cup

    Which in respect of an early FA Cup tie includes officials who have allowed on a 6th sub from the 5-0 winning team in the 88th min, whereby the game has been ordered to be replayed. I would not like to be in their shoes. These things shouldn’t happen but they do.
  15. D

    Whistle blast before 5 second count down.

    Sounds like you’ve been taking ideas from Sweet with the introduction of Ballroom Blitz and Manfred Mann with 5-4-3-2-1! There has been too much plagiarism going around at the moment! 😂 😂
  16. D

    Whistle blast before 5 second count down.

    If it was at the same meeting I was at the reply was provided by a L2 Referee. I know where L2/RDO were coming from. However, on IFABs Q&A page - A player appears to take a throw-in but suddenly leaves the ball to a team-mate. What action does the referee take? If the team is deliberately...
  17. D

    Whistle blast before 5 second count down.

    I have seen 4 games now and haven’t seen any confusion from players. Yes, it can be a bit of the pain having to use the whistle when it was usually the case to use sparingly, but it has produced the desired outcome of compliance. Having said that if a game has neutral Assistants, there are...
  18. D

    Law 5 Clarification

    20-30 seconds and longer than the Scottish clip shown within these threads.
  19. D

    Law 5 Clarification

    Just been watching the York v Crawley game. Player grounded for at least 10 seconds - no caution to the offender/no other exceptions in point - remained on the FoP & re-start delayed! Hopefully I missed something!
  20. D

    Law 5 Clarification

    Law 5.3 is quite specific whereby other than the exceptions “ …stops play only if a player is seriously injured and ensures that the player is removed from the field of play. An injured player may not be treated on the field of play and, where an injury results in play being stopped or the...
Back
Top