The Ref Stop

Search results

  1. R

    Man Utd v Tottenham

    I can't believe anyone would think that isn't a red card, he made contact with significant force and just had to be sent off. I also wouldn't say Shaw milked it as 99% of players would have gone to ground after contact like that, Shaw just held his head. I don't think there was enough for a...
  2. R

    West Ham v QPR

    If it's the same one I'm thinking of he didn't get the ball, looked like he did from the broadcast angle but then clearly didn't from the replay. But, and as @socal lurker has said, there are undoubtedly different thresholds for challenges on attackers in penalty areas than other challenges...
  3. R

    West Ham v QPR

    I don't think anyone in football expects that to be given as a foul. It was a controlled tackle, he won the ball clearly and I wouldn't say it was careless, certainly not reckless. I haven't heard anyone involved in football come out and say it was a correct decision, and I'm pretty sure Pro...
  4. R

    Garforth Town vs Ossett United

    Really not sure what happened there. Was he pointing for a goal or an IDFK for simulation? The fact that after the initial discussion with AR1 he signals a goal can only make me think the former, but the AR has then got him back over to say it can't be a goal as he blew the whistle before the...
  5. R

    Garforth Town vs Ossett United

    Time in the video? Not everyone will have time to watch the full match highlights.
  6. R

    Classic offside lesson

    I tried to get to the correct point of release but just couldn't, never let me be a VAR operator 😂 He's so far ahead of where he should be though that it is much more difficult than it should be, and whatever he does certainly wouldn't have been credible.
  7. R

    Classic offside lesson

    He should be static on the half way line ready to go as the second last defender is in the other half. It is natural reaction to set off early, but his position here makes me certain he has forgot about the keeper being missing and was tracking the last defender. Even from his position he...
  8. R

    Classic offside lesson

    Still think you are giving them too much credit. This was a rare offside situation, I'd compare it to when people in football claim it can't have been offside because the ball was played backwards. I've even seen referees get that one wrong, and that's the issue when you get decisions that...
  9. R

    Classic offside lesson

    True, we don't know what they were specifically complaining about, but I suspect you are giving them too much credit. Far more likely they just didn't realise offside is based on the second last defender.
  10. R

    Paris Vs Arsenal Ladies

    Absolutely, it has had a huge impact on the game, it has completely changed how most teams play out from defence. Whether it has improved the game will be a matter of opinion.
  11. R

    Classic offside lesson

    Kind of agree, but the counter argument to that is the AR had the half way line as reference so should be fairly easy to see he was offside.
  12. R

    Macedonia v Scotland

    No way that would be given in the EPL, but we know that in Europe if the ball hits your hand or arm and it isn't pinned by your side you are in a spot of jeopardy.
  13. R

    Advantage on an Offside Offense

    You can't really win, as if you play advantage and the keeper then miskicks it straight to an opponent the same coach will be demanding a free kick.
  14. R

    Ukraine vs Northern Ireland

    Agree, I can only assume the fact he missed with both legs, and only made contact with his trailing body, saved him. Stupid tackle, and lucky to get away with it, but I've seen worse non-VAR interventions.
  15. R

    throw in protocol

    That's the key point, to get to the sideline. Referees are only expected to start the countdown once a player is deemed to be taking too long. I watch a lot of football and as far as I can see they are applying it correctly, but this does include an element of common sense. Classic example...
  16. R

    Classic offside lesson

    The biggest mistake is the attacker, all he had to do was delay his run by a fraction of a second and he'd have been in his own half. Or his team mate who didn't need to pass the ball, he could have just carried on running, although they'd probably have then still stuffed it up by passing to...
  17. R

    Man City scandal: will it make reffing the upcoming Liverpool v City game harder?

    There's very little doubt that the Liverpool fans will find some creative ways to add to Man City's misery, that's just what football fans do. But I don't think it is likely to affect the match officials, once you get to that level you have learned to zone out of everything other than the game.
  18. R

    Open Age 'Get control of the game, ref!'

    I'd be tempted to respond with something like the one thing I definitely haven't lost control of is the ability to send you to the sin bin for 10 minutes, so I'd suggest you keep your opinions to yourself.
  19. R

    Penalty goalkeeper 'protest'

    It is, but that is a by product of the codes never having been updated since 1995 when SPA became a thing. Which just demonstrates how pointless they are, either keep them up to date or scrap them.
  20. R

    Penalty goalkeeper 'protest'

    Totally agree, it hasn’t been updated for decades and doesn’t reflect current law. The fact that SPA, probably the most common USB caution, isn’t on there says it all really. I’m far from convinced that the C1 caution codes are used for anything. I would guess that the person who created the...
Back
Top