The Ref Stop

Search results

  1. R

    Sunderland v Brighton DOGSO

    Couldn’t really make this up. Original decision was no red card. VAR recommended review and red card issued. Brighton appealed and were successful with suspension being removed. KMI panel say the red card was correct. That for me demonstrates why it can't have been a clear and obvious error, we...
  2. R

    Well that was unexpected…..

    I’d just assumed it was the global PHP issue.
  3. R

    VAR added time

    4th officials are instructed they MUST keep a stoppage log detailing all times the game was stopped where time should be added on. They then tell the referee how much time they think should be added, and unless the referee disagrees that is what will go up on the board. It is pretty much...
  4. R

    Shoving the Ref, Pt2: Man City vs PSG

    Sending off here would be totally OTT in my opinion. It is just a collision.
  5. R

    Sanctions

    Agree. In England if you are found to have not submitted cautions or sendings off you will be suspended. If on promotion you can also kiss goodbye to that. And it does happen as clubs contact the CFA to report they are missing, CFA check the system and they haven’t been submitted.
  6. R

    Lesson learnt

    As has been said, never tell a player he has to stay on his feet. That is a coaching instruction, can't be a refereeing one as slide tackles are perfectly legal.
  7. R

    Jacob Miles

    No one on here is going to know that unless they personally know Jacob. Referees get injured just like players do, I know that more than anyone, that would be my guess for the reason but can't know for sure.
  8. R

    Sunderland v Brighton DOGSO

    I don't think the attacker had a cat in hell's chance of getting to the ball before the keeper, so a big mistake for VAR to get involved. I was very confident their appeal would be successful on this. I think the independent panel will go to town on this one and say 5-0 that the original...
  9. R

    Open Age Abandoned

    I'd agree with that if he'd been sent off for something like DOGSO, but when it is VC that is much more of a risk
  10. R

    Coventry v Newcastle

    I prefer to go on what the law says rather than what AI says has happened. Even more so as for the Benrahma one it says he lifted it over his head, which is a mandatory caution.
  11. R

    Coventry v Newcastle

    Definitely not, just lifted it to show the message, at no point was the head covered. Hence why I think it was a refereeing mistake.
  12. R

    Coventry v Newcastle

    It does, but it also says that the player / team will be sanctioned by the competition organiser, national football association or FIFA. I would take the referee not being listed there as meaning they would just include it in a match report, not caution for it. The laws only reference a...
  13. R

    Open Age Abandoned

    I'm going to hazard a guess that he was still wearing the armband stood on the touchline and they haven't even thought about who would replace him. Once it was obvious the sent off player was going to refuse to go I'd stop engaging with him and rather try to persuade a "sensible" team mate to...
  14. R

    Coventry v Newcastle

    That was a fantastic advantage, would have been so easy to blow for a free kick there. I personally think he is one of the best, mainly because of how different he is. He has zero interest in being friendly or chatty with the players, rather adopts a very stern "stay away" approach, almost a...
  15. R

    Open Age Abandoned

    The league should absolutely back you here. They probably will be frustrated as it will take a couple of months for county to sort out, but that isn't your problem and you did the correct thing in applying the laws. Realistically the result at the time of the abandonment will end up standing...
  16. R

    mıstaken ıdentıty

    No, as far as I am aware they don't even look at club marks any more for promotion. Perhaps they look at marks for county cup games, but in my experience they don't even ask leagues to provide club marks like they used to. They do look at levels of administration, so just take the caution...
  17. R

    7-0 cup match players upset

    Assume you were on your own with no assistants? On the rare occasions I do games on my own I say to the captains at the toss that I won't be apologising for missing an offside. I tell them that I might be facing the wrong way when the ball is played, especially for long clearances, and I will...
  18. R

    Liverpool - Man C

    I've been trying to explain to my Liverpool supporting mates, once Kavanagh decides to give the free kick there could only be one outcome. If you are on a caution and you make that challenge you have to win the ball, if you don't you are walking.
  19. R

    Man Utd v Tottenham

    They will if the opponents are stupid enough to rise to it. They know if they move their head to an opponent and make significant contact they are walking, but they still do it.
  20. R

    Man Utd v Tottenham

    Because the guidelines for pushes have always been neck and above is red, below the neck is a caution. It is almost written into law now given it specifically talks about the head or face in the VC part of law 12. There have been lots of cases of a two handed push to the chest being sanctioned...
Back
Top