The Ref Stop

Search results

  1. R

    Liverpool vs Arsenal

    Perhaps if it wasn't in England, but no Pro Ref official is going to say DOGSO there because they are given expectations. But the chance of something happening when it hasn't happened in thousands of other games is surely miniscule.
  2. R

    Liverpool vs Arsenal

    I like Graham and he is a breath of fresh air as a refereeing pundit, but I don't think he is right here. If he was still on PGMO / Pro Ref and this happened there would be no way on earth he would have been issuing a red card for it. It just doesn't happen.
  3. R

    Player pacing out the wall - Dissent or Delaying?

    I remember in a Premier League game where a player was moaning about the wall distance. The referee then paced out 10 yards, took him exactly to the wall, paced 10 yards back and shoved a yellow card up the complainant's nose. Pretty sure it was Phil Dowd, or could have been Jeff Winter.
  4. R

    Man C v BHA - backpass claim

    For the potential back pass I'm pretty sure he plays it with his shin, a kick can only be with the foot therefore he can't have kicked it, deliberately or otherwise, to the keeper. As for the handball, absolutely no chance in my view. Both arms are in supportable positions and it bounces off...
  5. R

    Liverpool vs Arsenal

    I've been racking my brain but I can't remember a single case of a DOGSO red being given in a professional game when a player was fouled when going to head a cross. And I watch a lot of football, the expectation is that it is SPA as there's too much doubt about scoring. Take Mac Allister's...
  6. R

    Liverpool vs Arsenal

    Because the referee would need to have a certainty that he would be getting onto the end of the cross. I can't remember any occasions of DOGSO where it has been a cross in and a player who might have got onto the end of it being fouled.
  7. R

    Liverpool vs Arsenal

    It might be a missed penalty, but there's no way on earth it would have been a red card.
  8. R

    Man C v BHA - backpass claim

    It isn't, but you have to be confident that he intentionally played the ball back to the keeper. I'm just not seeing that, as someone who played centre back the only thing you are thinking about in that situation is not scoring an own goal. To think that someone sliding back towards his own...
  9. R

    Brentford v Liverpool VAR overrule

    Because he made absolutely no motion towards the opponent, there's nothing even vaguely violent about it.
  10. R

    Man C v BHA - backpass claim

    Clearly an interception for me, no way on earth am I giving an IDFK for that.
  11. R

    Fleetwood v Arsenal

    Anyone that has been on child protection training will know there are breaches and bad practice. It certainly isn't a breach, but someone shouting at or belittling a child is undoubtedly a case of bad practice. And yes, teachers aren't really allowed to shout at students these days. Not...
  12. R

    Fleetwood v Arsenal

    Absolutely that. Clearly the same laws have to apply to a 16 year old as anyone else playing in the game, but there are still potential safeguarding issues. Arteta was on very shaky ground with how he spoke to Dowman after the was sent off, in the eyes of the law he is a child and you cannot...
  13. R

    Fleetwood v Arsenal

    I definitely saw it somewhere, unless I've become a victim of AI. It does appear that I have been 🤦‍♂️
  14. R

    Fleetwood v Arsenal

    Appeal successful, decision overturned and suspension removed.
  15. R

    Fleetwood v Arsenal

    Unsurprisingly Arsenal have appealed, I’d be very surprised if this isn’t deemed wrong and the suspension removed
  16. R

    Fleetwood v Arsenal

    I'm not really seeing anything violent in that, he's gone to kick him but then pulled out, really don't see how that was excessive force or brutality. Fully expect that one will be overturned on appeal.
  17. R

    IFAB changes for 26-27

    It was always going to fail, partly because of how badly it would affect football with defences dropping off, but also it would make it impossible for ARs to judge offside. Fine for levels where VAR was in use, but for anyone else it would be nigh on impossible.
  18. R

    Ipswich v Forest missed DOGSO

    The description wasn't helpful, he didn't really knock it wide. But I do think the VAR intervention was incorrect, the attacker's touch before being fouled was heavy and even if he somehow got to the ball before it went out of play or the keeper got it it would have been an impossible angle...
  19. R

    Sunderland v Brighton DOGSO

    Agree, saying it was down to the direction wasn't really true as he was still moving almost directly towards goal. Rather his heavy touch meant there was zero chance of getting the ball, and even if he did it would have been a very acute angle.
  20. R

    Sunderland v Brighton DOGSO

    I'm pretty sure a 5th body, the referee observation panel (or whatever it is called) will determine whether the decisions impacts his mark, positively or negatively. That's the one outcome we will probably never find out about.
Back
Top