The Ref Stop

Search results

  1. R

    Sheffield Wednesday vs Plymouth

    That's the problem though, people with no background in refereeing will just remember the mistakes. As I said, aside from this decision I thought Anthony Backhouse was really good, but most supporters are describing it as one of the worst ever performances because they just remember this...
  2. R

    Sheffield Wednesday vs Plymouth

    Wasn't the keeper, it was a challenge by the right wing back out by the right touchline , Plymouth just have a very bright away kit.
  3. R

    Sheffield Wednesday vs Plymouth

    It was also quite early in the game which I suspect may well have played a part in the decision making progress.
  4. R

    Sheffield Wednesday vs Plymouth

    I was at this one yesterday and real time, even after one too many sherbets, I thought this was a red card. Having now seen it I am certain. A pity for Anthony Backhouse as he had a very good game aside from this one incident.
  5. R

    Arsenal Vs Hull

    That's the ideal world scenario, but the Mic'd Up show in reality wasn't set up to only show incorrect VAR interventions or non-interventions. There was always going to be an element of spin to it, and I think they will only show the really controversial ones if the football world are up in...
  6. R

    Arsenal Vs Hull

    He certainly couldn't have done that alone though as he has to say what the restart will be before the VAR process is finished. So if he said he was going offside surely one of the two senior FIFA officials in the VAR booth would have questioned that? I'm not sure we'll get the audio from this...
  7. R

    Man Utd v Villa

    Agree, also think we will see it added to law sooner rather than later.
  8. R

    Arsenal Vs Hull

    Whilst not saying it directly, Graham Scott today seemed to suggest that it was an intentional decision rather than not knowing the laws. He also mentioned how people would fail to have understood how a penalty was given but no DOGSO. It can't have been DOGSO as Havertz being offside means...
  9. R

    Man Utd v Villa

    Had Mbuemo been in an offside position he would certainly have been interfering with Suzuki, but he wasn't, there was a defender who hadn't got out quickly enough who was playing him on. No foul on Suzuki for me, contact isn't automatically a foul. Had the minor contact from Lammens affected...
  10. R

    Plaster as Shinpad

    I think it might be that material that hardens on impact. a bit like that in some mobile phone cases. I was sceptical, but then saw a live demo where the demonstrator but them on and got someone to whack him on the shins and they stopped the impact. Never seen them as stick on though, and I'd...
  11. R

    Crystal Palace vs Liverpool

    I can see why it was given, the Palace gets there first and heads the ball before any contact with Kerkez. I suspect Tony Harrington thought there was more movement towards Osario by Kerkez than there actually was, whereas for me it was more of a coming together. There's no doubt Osario headed...
  12. R

    Arsenal Vs Hull

    Yes but they were in previous seasons, doesn't mean guidance has been given out since.
  13. R

    Arsenal Vs Hull

    I can't help wondering if this is down to some kind of weird Pro Ref interpretation / guidance where despite what the laws say they expect this to be given as offside. Otherwise we have a situation where an elite FIFA referee and assistant referee in the VAR booth don't know the offside law...
  14. R

    Everton Vs Coventry - Hair Pulling

    Don't think so, it wouldn't have been a penalty for that level of holding of a shirt, they would say it wasn't sustained enough. So if they are saying that someone accidentally pulling hair when they go to grab a shirt is no longer a red card, I don't really see how it could be a foul either...
  15. R

    Everton Vs Coventry - Hair Pulling

    The comical thing is the very same people that complained about red cards for "accidental" hair pulling last season are now bemoaning this not being a red card. People have very short memories, leads back to my point about people saying they don't want VAR, the very second something serious was...
  16. R

    Leeds v Spurs

    Yeah, the angle from behind him very clearly shows it came off his shoulder. For Bogle's potential red card, I'm pretty sure they only took that long as Tel was down having treatment for the duration of the check, obviously can't restart whilst that is ongoing so it gave them time to check it...
  17. R

    Penalty - Completed "runup"?

    Can't see anything wrong at all here. There's nothing in law to say a penalty taker must take a run up, the whistle has been blown, just down to the keeper not concentrating. As an aside, the penalty taker in my old team used to do this. His rationale was he always placed them rather than...
  18. R

    New LoTG - Injuries - Liking it!!

    And that is where I'm coming from, the law changes have made it vastly better for spectators. Players may not like it, but it is them that caused the law change in the first place.
  19. R

    New LoTG - Injuries - Liking it!!

    It is working perfectly from what I can see. Previously there were multiple occasions in every game of players going down injured only to then pop back up once play was stopped, now it it just doesn't happen. Or course there is the side effect that players who are genuinely injured now have to...
  20. R

    Liverpool vs Arsenal

    Not really ... ... I can't make a call on DOGSO if I miss it completely 😂
Back
Top