Search results

Schrödinger reference was because it could be both DOGSO and not DOGSO at the same time. Never going to convince everyone of either argument.

Ha ha. It’s actually a shortened version of a theoretical discussion with myself and where I came out on it. Ultimately I put myself in that situation - I need to make an immediate call, what am I doing? The clinchers - attacker appealing for handball and the guilty look of the keeper as he...

I can’t call DOGSO on that. He fumbles and regathers almost immediately, gambling he can do so before it’s out of the penalty area. Physics means he can’t do so. And his body is always between the attacker and the ball. I can’t take him out of the equation because he has created any...

Tie finished 3-3 so they swapped one shooting match for another.

Two fowls occur at the same time. What is the appropriate action?

Home team goalkeeper took a goal kick, and away defenders have pushed up to halfway as all the kicks have been landing short. This left a home attacker all on his own between them and the goal. Ball clears everyone, one bounce to the attacker now one on one with the goalkeeper. He takes a...

That’s also a fair outcome I did consider if we think it’s taken incorrectly. I went down the route of not an attempt to throw the ball in at all.

Throw in to white as the restart. 😏 Ball hadn’t gone behind his head at any stage on that video, so it’s a deliberate act of violent conduct when the ball is out of play. But that’s being obtuse - direct free kick, nobody really complains as they’re still in WTF mode

Whilst it’s true that there are none so blind as those who will not see, let’s keep this civil and not allow it to escalate. 🙂

Totally understand the complexity argument. But in the last 5 ties I’ve done it’s been 16-2 (yesterday), 11-0, 6-0, 10-0 and 3-0. Only the last was competitive. In my CFA - Berks and Bucks - at least given it’s such a wide geographic area I think splitting into two levels would be useful. Like...

The handball was given on field, and the replays I’ve seen were inconclusive. If the VAR sees the same as I did then On field call has to stand in this case.

Easiest to give these as fouls. At least in part the jump is designed to intimidate and cause the player to back out as happened on one of the occasions you’ve described. And of course if it does go wrong then you’re looking at a potentially serious injury. Try and nip it in the bud if you...

Remember that eye roll inducing bad joke? “I reckon it’ll be one each, even the goalkeeper will score” That happened this morning in my County Cup game. Woefully mismatched sides, score well into double figures with the goalkeeper scoring the first of the second half. 12 different scorers all...

This isn’t a great start, and warning points have now been issued for comments attacking other members. We won’t stand for it. This is a public warning to everyone. We’ve seen far too much of this recently and now we’re drawing a line. As for your original post, you asked a question and the...

According to Blackpool Gazette it wasn’t called off, but delayed pending second inspection at 7:30. Certainly a breakdown in communication somewhere, but not sure this is on the officiating team? Seems to be on Tranmere not advising people.

Enough. One persons continued needling and antagonistic behaviour has caused this to shut down. You have been warned before. Stop it.

Both feet off the floor as he jumps into the challenge. I missed in real time and thought a caution was about right, but the replay showed me something else.

If it hits the rear arm (right arm?) then it’s given. Hitting the front arm, I can understand overturning the call. Not quite sure where it’s supposed to go.

Going back several years for this example admittedly, but sent a player off for violent conduct against another player. Reported all comments on the same charge sheet and he had it all lumped together into a more serious misconduct charge. That’s where my approach has come from. If they’re...

Red for VC and describe the incident in the report exactly as you have. Don’t mess around with extraordinary reports as it’s all one incident. Let the disciplinary panel do that; especially now there’s a dedicated team who are paid to handle these cases.