Search results

I will leave it to those who know a lot more than me ad most will but law 12 includes dogso and them considerations with a C. All good anyway. Good night.

. As others have said including the former top ref Keith you can see this differently. Why they are doing what they are doing really should be a consideration and again there are refs on this thread who are considering that to hold merit. And that was it. A difference of opinion on laws that...

Nothing invented. I would apply them laws to this. As others have said no obvious dogso including top ex refs on that x . Too much going on. Disagree agree and this one Its just a matter of differing perception this one.

The considerations in the rules are not made up. Which is why in my first post I have asked dogso? The defender would have gone to the attacking player space if the gk didn't. The keepers up sharp to narrow the angle and push the attacking player away from goal. The touch does take the player...

I am merely asking some whys. Thats it in regards to the Sheff W players I am not making up my interpretations regarding what they are doing at this point. They started out of shape and move into pretty text book defending principles to get to this point where Bannan? then upends the attacker...

As a very qualified coach ex semi pro defender and now well meaning trying to always do better ref the process is D deny space, D delay D dictate D depth and the defender are hitting d's because they 100% are not off to the goal line!! The keeper is denying space and attempting to dictate where...

Thank you. My understanding was there. I am not in detention. At one point the defender is between the attacker and gk marginally but the big point was its not 1v1 and the keeper comes across the defender towards the attacker and his team mate adjusts position to cover the goal and they both...

I use this to forum to learn. DOGSO test DDDC is?

Dont thInk he is edge of six yard, and the gk comes across and the defender covers the space and shapes to help the gk force the attacker outside if the foul wasnt committed so both gk and defender are not dropping to the goaline regardless. Thats denying space not dropping.

That is the screenshot from when contact was made.

The attacker is going towards the defender because of his touch, a defender who will be between him and the keeper..

Taking everything into consideration its not 1v1.

This was a sending off? This isn't clear dogso?

Thank you. I have commented on the use of balance, and natural in the thread. What IFAB appear to expect is unnatural, and physically illogical. Thanks. Its a tough gig. I use these threads to educate myself. I have learned something, but wont be inflicting it on the u12's, u13's .. etc I...

My experience isn't limited, Its my job. My knowledge, my qualifications and the now several thousand hours of performing my roles puts my expertise at expert level ... Unlike my refereeing.

My view is not anecdotal. Its evidence based. We move our arms to balance rotational movements. Rapid limb movements (those leg extensions) require use of arms to control our centre of mass and dynamic movement. These movements will also not be exact individual to individual as we do not share...

USB -Yellow card.

If you reread the thread I posed a similar question. So, do not beg, I have performed that movement frequently over thirty years of playing, training and as a coach of ten plus years I can witness this natural movement. Raised arms. Reach for the ball with a leg and you will use...

So your natural position has no measurement. It is all about context. Here is context. A norm and a logical expectation is bipedal movement where the arms move in opposite direction to leg movement. This is normal physical movement. The player (Luton v Wolves) was displaying a natural (normal)...

The player did not run towards the opponent waving an arm in the air. His arm is in that position because of his own movement in attempting to block the football. Are you stating that an arm above a certain angle is unnatural? What is the exact angle the arm can be taking into consideration...