Search results

What minute was that in the game?

Here: https://www.dutchreferee.com/esfandiar-baharmast-saw-something-16-cameras-couldnt-see/

Penalty for me

It was saved by the keeper, I was surprised there was no retake

Hi Jan, great to see you back :)

What minute did this incident occure?

I think the yellow card would be for unsporting behaviour. That being said, I think if the goalkeeper keeps out a bad back pass to him with his hands, I think it is no card a.t.m, so that doesn't make much sense.

At what time did that happen?

I agree that this would mean a even harder job for defenders, and I'm not sure if it would work (especially on non-pro level). But it would, for me at least, be much easier to call a foul or not. And that is key for me - more consistency on the calls.

I mean, what players ACTUALLY play a ball deliberately with their hands. Yes, maybe Luis' Suarez save at the world cup or Chamberlains handball against Chelsea (ball was going wide^^) but other than that - noone wants to deliberately give away a penalty. The problem is, the word is used wrongly...

The handball rule needs revision! I heard that the term "deliberate" will be taken out. Good! I would suggest something like "can the player anticipate the ball" - i think Young can.

Can you tell me in which minututes of the game these two offenses took place?

Not enough for me Sheffiels Finest, I think V. Dijks shirt is also pulled in that situation. What about the yellow on Lovren (43'). If he didn't foul him, would it not have been a goalscoring opportunity? El Shaarawy had a good touch which put the ball quite centraly. Thoughts?

Funny reaction by Jürgen Klopp being asked about the penalty incident! At 9:00

Should be a drop ball if he cautions both players, right? But as West Brom get the free kick after, Livermoore -as sugested- probably got a yellow for something else after the initial foul...

I don't think Livermoore deserved yellow for his tackle - funny how he didn't get injured and wasn't mad at A.Smith at all, who needed short treatment. incident around 35min

I thought i would share this cool Offside Test, where you have to decide whether it is deliberate play or a deflection! Quite tricky if you ask me :p https://www.proassistantreferees.com/deliberate-deflection/ I am a big fan of the content of our American friends from PRO (proreferees.com and...

Sooo... is Lamela attempting to play the ball and is fouled after? Looks like it to me. He's deffinitely challenging for the ball.

Wow, this brings a whole new dimension to the video "proof". I mean, this is so hard to spot in real time and even with several camera angles it is uncertain. The argument, that Lamela walks into the challenge and it therefore isn't a foul is not valid for me. Good players often draw fouls by...

Hello Everyone I watched the game and even as a Liverpool fan, i thought the two penalties were rightly awarded. I found a camera angle I think has not been uploaded here yet, which for me clearly proves, that Lamela has been caught sufficently to go down. here is the link: