The Ref Stop

Search results

  1. halter42

    retrospective action?

    Here is a link: https://streamable.com/527eda For me it is a clear RC, I don't care if Grealish milks it, it's a strike to the head to me.
  2. halter42

    Goalkeeper handball DOGSO (inside penalty area)?

    Hi @spuddy1878, this is the link: But it is a private group, so you have to make an account. Just make a fake one like I did, doesn't matter. You have to request to join the group, they will add you soon after.
  3. halter42

    Goalkeeper handball DOGSO (inside penalty area)?

    Hello Jack. I can recommend to join Refcoach's facebook group. Just recently they posted a clip form the greek league, where the goalkeeper commits exactly the offence you are describing. Joing here: https://www.facebook.com/groups/427274501289694
  4. halter42

    LEE SHE - Baldock lucky?

    I agree with rusty ref, this is not a red card for me. Baldock lost balance, but it was not very dangerous, no hard contact with the studs.
  5. halter42

    Ars Leeds VAR

    I didn't see the side-on view. Where did they show it, MOTD?
  6. halter42

    WBA V Man City

    Here is the video without geoblock. https://streamable.com/0itupp
  7. halter42

    Liv Manu

    I checked the footage again. He last checked his watch (probably started the timer) 4 seconds before the ball was kicked. That was probably the reason why he blew earlier.
  8. halter42

    Supercopa semi final

    It's interesting, because even if Casemiro plays the ball backwards, Benzema can still be offside. (Many people think it can't, because it's played backwards.)
  9. halter42

    SOU Vs WHU

    For me, it's a RC. Endangering the safety of the opponent. No intent, of course, but it doesn't matter. I have seen many RC, where the offender didn't mean it/it was accidental.
  10. halter42

    Nani Red Card

    I also think it is a RC. But I'm open to see it differently. The fact that #08COL made a big step and did not have his foot planted there for long could be an argument. I think this is similiar: (Umtiti vs. Colombia). And this one is probably a clearer RC, the force is higher: (v.Dijk vs...
  11. halter42

    Villa vs Utd

    It's not a penalty for me. YC for Fernandez would be good. If you look at the point of contact you would have to go red, but if it's really accidental there are situations (like falling on someone after a header) where you don't have to punish that hard.
  12. halter42

    Bournmouth v Spurs

    I thought it was a very interesting scene. I think Kane is very quick in realising that he won't get to the ball, once he feels contact in the back. So he falls. I think if we look at it frame by frame I would say rather no penalty and theatrical fall - BUT it's one of those where the majority...
  13. halter42

    Brig v Man Utd

    What are you refering to? Offside? It probably wasn't - the angle can be deceiving
  14. halter42

    Decision Clips

    Have a look here. I really enjoyed Instant Replay from MLS, but you have to make your own judgement, it's not the official guideline.
  15. halter42

    Dutch Referee Blog - Week 26 Laws of the Game Quiz 2019-2020

    I thought exactly the same thing. In my head I was like: ok, just ignore the part that there has been scored a goal before.
  16. halter42

    GK Handball in the Middle of the Pitch

    Tweet is unavailable for me.
  17. halter42

    And we thought we had seen everything.....

    It's not the first time this happened. Ryan Donk in Süper Lig (Turkey): :D
  18. halter42

    Turkish Game: Genclerbirligi v Gazisehir

    I personally think yellow card and penalty is acceptable. I was also thinking about violent conduct, but it was not much force in it.
  19. halter42

    Turkish Game: Genclerbirligi v Gazisehir

    Hello, it has been taken down. Here I found the clip: https://yfl.tostreamit.com/embed00/OpmgnyO8mi The situation starts at 1:34.
Back
Top