Nottingham Forest vs Aston Villa
- Thread starter WillH
- Start date
FirsFox40
RefChat Addict
*cough*
No attempt to play the ball so the yellow still stands right?
The yellow would still be for SPA if we're being technical. It just doesn't get downgraded in the penalty area because it was a hold.
David F
Member
Agree this is a pen, and not “fleeting” since it has an immediate impact on the attacking player.
Question on the VAR protocol - if the VAR believes that the pull is a clear and obvious offence, but also that the tug of the shirt by Rogers on Anderson just before is a possible foul (but not clear and obvious) is this still a penalty review, or does the fact that Rogers’ action was a possible foul mean that the PK is no longer clear and obvious?
Question on the VAR protocol - if the VAR believes that the pull is a clear and obvious offence, but also that the tug of the shirt by Rogers on Anderson just before is a possible foul (but not clear and obvious) is this still a penalty review, or does the fact that Rogers’ action was a possible foul mean that the PK is no longer clear and obvious?
If we go off the VAR protocol based in the actual laws (and not whatever the PL is up to) the correct procedure would be to bring the ref to the monitor for a clear PK (which I think it was) and then allow the ref to make the final decision about a possible foul in the APP.
David F
Member
Also is “fleeting” even a consideration when the attacking player is in possession of the ball? Feels like this guidance should only be for holding in the area when a cross is coming in, not for when a player is running with the ball. Most pull-backs are fleeting but they’re still fouls, and usually cautions.
Any pull/holding is only an offence if it impedes the opponent’s movement, so I would say that how "fleeting" it is is definitely relevant.
best save ive seen in quite a white absolutely no idea how he did that. Could have also potentially been a yellow for hudson odoi there for simulation
Checking Possible Offside..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................Ah sod it, we've missed last orders
You could argue they were both guilty of pulling & shirt holding, I suspect both referee & VAR deemed it was 50/50 on holding & pulling?
Jamie Redknapp argues Aston Villa should have been awarded a penalty against Nottingham Forest
Jamie Redknapp believes Aston Villas Morgan Rogers should have been awarded a penalty against Nottingham Forest in the first half of their Premier League clash.