-
-
WWiisardNic reacted to socal lurker's post in the thread Handball penalty - red, yellow, nothing? with
Like.
Definition in LOTG: Deliberate An action which the player intended/meant to make; it is not a ‘reflex’ or unintended reaction as @one... -
WIs that your take from the media release? My beef is with making it prescriptive or one size fits all. It is a very subjective...
-
WWiisardNic replied to the thread Handball penalty - red, yellow, nothing?.I mean.. the way I read the release is that at any level IFAB doesn't expect a foul. But I'm kind of on your camp (from posts above)...
-
WIFAB media 🙄 Why do I ever need to use my head to header the ball when I have my hands "to protect it". A better angle. I take that...
-
WWiisardNic reacted to RefereeX's post in the thread Handball penalty - red, yellow, nothing? with Like.
I still think this has to be considered deliberate in a sense. She may not have made a conscious decision to catch the ball but her body...
-
WWiisardNic replied to the thread Handball penalty - red, yellow, nothing?.At the professional level, yes.
-
WWiisardNic replied to the thread Handball penalty - red, yellow, nothing?.Eh.. yes and no. If it just blocks the shot, then yes - that is relevant. But does that extend to completely catching the ball?
-
WI hate that as well, and on a few occasions when I felt the player didn't have a chance to move away and the opponent tries to get him...
-
WWiisardNic replied to the thread Handball penalty - red, yellow, nothing?.Devils advocate question: Would you consider an amateur instinct as 'deliberate'? I've never had it happen in the penalty area, but have...
-
WWiisardNic reacted to OldNavyRef's post in the thread DOGSO in the penalty area situation with Like.
I am basing this on you saying the decision was correct. Meaning that in order for it to be a caution instead of a dismissal it must...
-
WI was going to mention this in my post that it has been discussed here a few times before. In football we don't want to award a goal...
-
WNot so sure I'm seeing it that way. More often than not, the CAR is just a mis-employed substitute who (normally reluctantly) has...
-
WIt’s the jump up before the slide that does it for me. Had she slid in normally………
-
WBut CARs often cheat. I am not saying offer CARs no protection cause that is ludicrous and extremely poor refereeing. But to pretend...
-
-
Loading…
-
Loading…